Quote: NickyKiss "To highlight I'm trying to be as neutral as possible, I'd pick Makinson as well and would pick him ahead of any winger in Superleague because I think he's the best around but by the same token, I wouldn't take Welsby over Field or French, regardless of stats. The naked eye tells me Makinson is the best winger in the league but the naked eye doesn't say to me that Welsby is the best player in the league and stats just back that view up. He's one of the best (top 5 IMO) and that is playing at fullback, which I think is his second best position and he's younger than the other guys I'd have in that bracket, so his ceiling is probably higher but I think it's a bit media driven this line of 'Welsby is the best in the league'. If you're not as good in attack or defence as another fullback in the league, I'm stumped how anybody could give a concrete opinion of him being the leagues best player.'"
It’s not a concrete opinion though is it? It’s just mine which you disagree with and that’s fine.
I did say very early on in many ways it’s a pointless debate.