Quote: 100% Warrior "I’d have Gildart back. Yes his last season was poor but to forget about his years of excellence is unfair. '"
Maybe so, but you can only judge players on their most recent contributions.
Just because he used to be good, we didn't see any of that in his last year, and I haven't seen anything better from him to date in the NRL (although admittedly, I don't watch too much NRL these days).
IF (and that's a big "if"icon_wink.gif we are to consider offering him a contract, it would have to be based 100% on the player he is right now - Not the guy that he used to be, who may never return.