Quote: moto748 "Barba is a different class to ZH; I struggle to see how anyone could deny that. '"
Purely offensively you might have a point as Barba is a devastating runner with ball in hand whilst Hardaker is only very good (but he is very good). Barba also has the edge passing wise.
There are, however, two sides to being a full back. Hardaker is streets ahead of Barba as a defender and probably worth a few wins a season on that basis alone.
So basically, unless you're just obsessed with the razzle dazzle and you don't care so much about what happens when the opposition has the ball then you could certainly pose an argument that either is the better fullback. It just depends what you need.
One thing's for certain, we (Leeds) have missed him.