Not a good move IMO. Though I think TL is a better player based on his age and recent injury record I don't think it's good business. I know Smith has had his problems and isn't a world beater he is rarely unavailable and also is the best goal kicker we have. Smith's performances have improved significantly since the return of Williams and Tomkins which shows how much pressure he was shouldering while they were out.

Leuluai was only good for us when he moved to 9. I'd be delighted to rotate him and McIllorum there.

Seriously??? Did you miss the 2010 season then?

Tommy Leuluai was excellent for us at 6,7 or 9. He's a fantastic player but his injury record is a concern.

If only we had a rumours thread for these type of things.