Give him the benefit , wait till the league games start but he has a lot to do !

I don't disagree. I think he's out of his depth at Wigan, almost as if he never realised - and still doesn't - just what's expected of him.

Season hasn't started yet but I hope he proves you wrong (just not against Trinity!).

I was impressed with his first stint at Leigh at the weekend. Worked hard and made some good metres playing at Loose. Then in the second half he must have dropped at least 3 balls and didn't do near as much work. Kind of sums him up as a player really... He just doesn't have any sort of consistency. After his performance at Leigh, Joe Bretherton will be right in the mix this year. Stood up well against a big Leigh pack, impressive.

Frustrating.

Does some really good things in attack but his style comes at a price as his rampaging efforts seem to result in him losing the ball.

We need to find another Scott Taylor.

This. He's strong as a bull, but we need him to stick his hands in glue before a game.