Quote: bazdev "What about Anthony Watmough for Parramatta? What about Ben Barba for Brisbane and Cronulla? Tomkins is never in a million years the worst signing, at the end of season 1 he was being talked about being a success after a slow start, the second he wanted to leave he became the biggest flop ever.
Was he a roaring success - probably not, was he a massive flop - probably not, he was a decent signing playing in a poor side. The article calls his 48% win percentage. Very similar to Shaun Johnson, is he a flop also?'"
Adam Blair and Braith Anasta both for Wests Tigers were pretty bad.