...like there was with Harris & Leeds?

And how did that turn out for championship side Bradford?

He's obsessed with comparing RL to other sports. Does my head in when he's on commentary "If this was a boxing match..." "I was watching the athletics today and..." Bore off

NRL is the bigtime.

Not ing about scoring tries in the SL playoffs vs Widnes/Hull.

Homesick my bum, he's been a flop. All the NRL Warriors highlights i've seen have involved him missing a tackle of being outpaced.

thats it then, end of debate..........

Go and lie down in a dark room... All that Easter chocolate has made you go all peculiar...

So what you're saying is that you expect him to flourish now he's coming back to SL? I agree!

He was clearly unsettled from the start and was still one of NZ's best players. Hope IL brings him on the pitch at half time against Catalan!

He never made it as big over there as Hall and Watkins, I'll admit ... oh, hang on.

I've watched most games he's played in and to say he has been a flop is harsh. He had a bit of a slow start but once he got going he started playing some slick stuff. Particularly along the right side attack he set up quite a few tries for Conrad Hurrell. Ultimately he's playing for one of the "weaker" sides and the fact that he also plays alongside Shaun Johnson makes it hard for him to establish himself when he doesn't get used in the same way or anywhere near as much as he did at Wigan.

Granted he's hardly done a Sam Burgess and won an NRL title... but he has hardly disgraced himself. If he does come back to the superleague I suspect he will come back a better player for his experience over there playing some quality sides every week.

Yeh I agree with that. The thing is, last season the NZW were playing to systems which meant that Tomkins didn't get his hands on the ball in attacking positions anywhere near as often as he did at Wigan, where all our attacking systems were basically designed to get him in space. His return for tries and assists was still pretty decent with this in mind, and for a team that didn't even reach the playoffs. From the two games Tomkins has played this season it looked like they were utilising him a lot better in attack, and his injury has been pretty unfortunate because I think he was in for a big season.

I really hope he comes back to Wigan, but I hope he shows the NRL just how good he is before he comes back.