Quote: DaveO "Spot on. At least someone recognises that this new system is in reality the return of P&R with all the negatives.
I'll guarantee you won't see a promoted side doing as Widnes did. In fact I reckon Betts would have been replaced by a more experienced coach never mind half the team were the new system in place rather than being given time to develop as a coach and build a team as he has been.'"
I also forgot to mention how immunity from relegation helped stabilise Catalan as well. Like Wines they were allowed time to bed in at this level. They were given time to gamble with unknowns such as Bosc, Fakir, Elima etc. I can't for the life of me seeing any championship side doing the same with the threat of relegation looming. Its obvious that they will take short term strategy and live from season to season.
That short term thinking, for me, devalues the competition.
History is littered with the failures of P&R.