Hi All, been reading and lurking for a while and finally decided to post on here. This may have been covered before with regards to offside but is there any point the touch judges call this? Never seems to be a TJ call on offside or much else these days.

Apologies if this will drag us off topic too but should we not incorporate the NRL video ref style now. Still make our refs make a decision instead of them going I'm not sure let someone else do it

The touch judges are mic'd up to the ref. They often have input on offsides but fans won't be aware when it's happened

It just seems there's a lot missed that is infront of their eyes. do we think the ref's are over ruling them more often than not?

Depends where it is on the pitch, whether the player gets involved etc. The ref is the arbitrator of the game after all so the buck stops with him really. Having said that I do sit in the stands sometimes and think I'm watching a different game to some people with the amount of time they spend shouting 'offside' and 'forward'. How boring the game would be if they were all given!

It's also true that many of us will has been critical of a decision when at the ground, only to find out later that the ref's were actually right, and we were wrong.. Thats the fun of it all. And, of course, Ref's make mistakes too, as do the players.

Whether they can hear or take note in the heat of the moment is another thing though. Wigan had a try against someone at the DW last year and the touch judge had shouted off side but Bentham had given the try before saying "did someone shout off side".....but it was too late as he'd given it.

Might have been a forward rather than off side but its the same point. You can hear the ref communications on the Wigan TV Coverage. Useful sometimes. Although I think they should have commentary on instead.

Are you touting for the job?

Did the TJ not stand off the flag to indicate no try?

Thats true, the amount of fans round us who regularly shout get em onside as soon as the 1st PTB is amazing. Sure they haven't taken note of where everyone is it's just a standard shout for them

I did ask the question @RLferees #askthe ref and the answer was No we cannot check for offside on the 10 metres, it's an onfield decision.

Fair does, you live and you learn!