Much rather have Scott Mcavoy tbh!

would we be wasting our time by sending him to Scorpions if we didn't want him, played at the weekend 1 try and 5 goals

I quite like Murphy as a full back could probably do with a full season loan somewhere though.

I like Murphy when he gathers the ball but the amount of errors he makes for a fullback is criminal. I've only really seen him in the first team at Wigan and Salford though so maybe regular watchers of the U20's in previous seasons could give better judgements. He's looked a bag of nerves at times but maybe that is understandable after having his confidence knocked in that Leeds game last year.

A game like tomorrow's wouldn't be a bad time to let him have another crack in the first team.

Weaker.

However it wont matter because Super League gets weaker every year and as a top side it subsequently wont make a scrap of difference.

Very true, but in fairness, even Sam isn't the greatest in that department either. It's always a balance with what they offer in attack, and the role of the fullback has changed a lot in recent years.