Quote: j.c "Actually ,i think it was meant to cure all rl ills,it never had a chance ,but i think that was the dream.'"
Not it wasn't. It was just part of his vision for a Super League.
Quote: j.c "No you would't have had bigger clubs,am at a loss as to why you would think that.
He was wrong as usual,'"
Given the problems experienced by the smaller clubs particularly in West Yorkshire I think he spotted a long time ago what the problems were and they are still with us today. His solution (as I said) wasn't going to work because fans of the clubs to make up the likes of Calder were not going to accept it. That was their prerogative but they have to accept the consequences i.e they remain small clubs that can't compete.
As to why you would have had bigger clubs that is patently obvious in that the idea was to combine a number of small clubs in an areas into one larger club.
He will also eventually be proved right. Not that we will end up with merged clubs but that sooner or later the small clubs won't be part of SL.
The merger idea was also his way of giving the fans of these small clubs something to shout for at the top of the sport. The fact it was rejected didn't surprise me at all but the last thing that does is show he wasn't on the right lines in that he viewed certain smaller clubs as incompatible and unsustainable in a professional sport.
He knew that was the case and I think he has been proved right as the teams he wanted to merge (who are still in SL) are consistently some of the lowest supported with the least chance of sporting success.