I meant punish as in penalty/sin bin/sending off depending on the severity/intention. Not banning anything.

Shoulder charges are executed (

) all the time by the ball carrier.

Be tick and pass soon

To be clear, are you suggesting no tackles are outlawed unless it is intended to injure or someone is injured? So the shoulder charge, spear tackle, chicken wing, Lima tackle into the knees, are all acceptable unless there is injury?

Did I say 'Not banning anything'. It appears I did, sorry.

I think you know what I meant

Spear tackle, chicken wing, Lima tackle into the knees, are not acceptable. No need to ban the shoulder charge UNLESS it's illegal. ie attack to the head etc.

All I'm saying, again, is shoulder charges have been going on for ever by the ball carrier and if he/she attacks the defender's head with the shoulder, arm, elbow, there's a penalty.

I didn't which is why I asked.



On that basis I agree.

Physical contact is what the sports all about!

This move is designed to look after the players but I'm not sure even they will back the move.

The fans certainly won't!!

looks like the oz coaches aren't happy about it ([urlhttp://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/arl-commission-bans-shoulder-charge-from-rugby-league/story-fndujljl-1226520747167[/url).

i can see penalty counts through the roof in the first few games if this is ratified (still some small hope it'll get reversed next month by the looks of it - but i'm not holding my breath)

It's bloody ridiculous. It's a great part of the game, just looking on YouTube, how many videos of "big hits" are full of massive shoulder hits.

Sod it, we may as well go watch some penalty shoot outs - sorry, rugby union!

Probably good idea. I don't mind shoulder charges per se but more often than not they are targeted at the head and why they are hardly ever penalised as a high tackle is a mystery to me. Probably more dangerous than a swinging arm.

When it comes off it looks spectacular, however i have seen it creeping into junior rugby more and more and i see lads using it [and more often than not missing when they should be putting their shoulder into a tackle..i think it should be allowed but definately shouldn't be encouraged in the junior game

so we can expect the video ref at all our games too then yes ????