Personally, if i was a player i would want some one like Faz or Peacock leading the way.
I have voted for Faz for two reasons
1. I am a Wigan fan
2. He single handedly dragged a poor Wigan team from the front during the beginning of our dark days. Game after game he led from the front without compromise. Those who did not see he performances week in may not appreciate how much he did for us during that period.
One thing i will say, is that Captains are often knocked for not being vocal enough and screaming at players when under the sticks.
None of the above are really that vocal a player and are more renown for setting an example as opposed to ranting and raving. Farrell especially got stick from our speccie's for not having kittens when we had conceded.
Food for though perhaps, for those who think that a skipper needs to through a double 6 when the going gets tough.