Eastmonds too injury prone (as said already in this thread).
Graham will sign a bumper new deal with them, and will be made captain to sweeten the deal for him.
Roby is a player I like, but I see him heading to Oz tbh.

That is a massive comment to make tbh, Hoffman has a lot more experience than the majority of the players named there, plus he's only here for a season (maybe 2)

Wouldn't have Eastmond. Can have the occasional great game, but too inconsistent and too injury-prone.

Graham & Roby, possibly, but wouldn't break the bank for them.

would have graham . He is a cracking player.

I think it is perhaps a tad too early to say he is injury prone. Has he just been unlucky or is he truly injury prone? If you could guarantee his fitness, then yes I would have him without hesitation. Sadly, jou cannot guarantee it, but I would probably still have a gamble and take him, but obviously the price/contract would have to reflect this. If any Saints fans are reading this, would you want him to go (obviously not to Wigan)?

As for getting shut of Hoffman (never seen play) and Amos (probably in the same bracket as Eastmond above), don't talk wet.

You can't just ignore Eastmond's injury record; at present, that blows away any notion that he's a guaranteed England 6 for the next decade. For a youngster, he's on the treatment bench with alarming regularity. Sure, he may just have been astonishingly unlucky, but quite often this sort of thing means that either his body's not up to the game or his head isn't. In any case, in the few times when Amos fired last season, he looked 20 times more deadly than I've ever seen Eastmond (though admittedly I've only seen Eastmond's TV games).

At the end of the day, I'd love to have a talent at Wigan like Eastmond, but not the way he is at present, and not at the expense of the two players you mention. Now Roby might be another matter. If Roby was available, I'd seriously hope Wigan would be enquiring.

Agree, but I think he's off to Oz

my thoughts exactly, exciting prospect at first but gets injured too often for me. Maybe union will give him a run, werent they after him last season or something?

Roby please.

All three are brilliant players and I would love to see them at Wigan.

I think Hoffman will be a lot more of an asset to us than some people think. In those big home games we lost last season (Saints, Wire, Leeds in the play-offs and even Hudds) we definately lacked that bit of experience and steel in our pack. Someone who will make the right decisions when the pressure is really on. Tuson and Farrell are great talents but their lack of experience did show at times which is understandable.