Good to watch you say? Nice how the Ref deals out discipline you say? Even -handed would you say? :

Hmmm ..... let's see now, oh yes, Peacock wasn't sin binned for the 2 high shots on Sam Tomkins, nor was Senior for kicking out 4 feet into the air causing Joel Tomkins 8 stitches to his eyebrow!

However, Liam Farrell (and you can watch the video in vain to prove me wrong) was actually in the air when Maguire kicked the ball. Call me cynical, but it's a little difficult to twist and change direction in mid-air don't you think. He then collides a little onto Maguire, who rolls over as if steamrollered by a 30-stone forward.

So who deserved sin-binning? According to Bentham Farrell was the only one. Coincidence, but the 3 games we have lost this year have had one thing in common. Can you guess what this might be?

Agree with you up to this point, but how can you compete for the ball with your arms by your side and looking in the wrong direction?

He was talking about the Alibert decision 1st half (not the Farrell sin binning) when we challenged Smith in the air and it should have been back to 1.

Crusaders 5 mins watching the game expert says it should have been penalty to Leeds as you can't "TOUCH" a player when going for the Ball!

Our guys just pointing out that you can touch him, you just can't tackle him as long as your making a genuine effort to catch the ball which I believe our players did?

So why didn't the VR give a penalty then?

He gave play on "Handover" meaning he thought a Wigan player must have touched it for it to be play on.

IMO and in about 99% of peoples opinions so far they think SMith touched it, Bad decision, end of, Nowt to get too worked up over.

Your comment earlier though was that "You can't touch a player when going for the Ball". Your wrong, you can Touch a player, You can't touch him if you aren't challenging, every Wigan player was.

From a Leeds fan's point of view it was a terrible call by the video referee, it should have been play on and another set for Wigan.

Just to prove it was no fluke though, the same official awarded a Bradford try yesterday after a clear knock on. Worryingly the TV coverage claimed he saw the touch (by Menzies) but it went backwards.

Referees (like most humans make mistakes) and that's to be expected. Video referees should not however, especially in such clear-cut situations.