Quote SHIPLEYGIANT="SHIPLEYGIANT"I can't comment on the game at the weekend as I havent seen it to be honest but we suffered this last season when we won games Coaches were quick to criticise our style of play. I think if you read the BBC in another comment NB has no qualms about Wigan being better than us on the day - it was more around the challenge by O'loughlin (again can't comment on it as I havent seen it unfortunately).
As far as I have seen he has made no reference to any other incident than the one above. I think his comments are more on the state of the game in the UK here than Wigan RLFC. If you re read his comments on the BBC he actually says that Darrell Griffin should have got a 2 game ban last year for a 'grapple tackle' but got nothing. He has used a Giants player to further make and justify his point.
Red Hall are just too inconsistent.'"
I'm not sure what the penalty for a grapple tackle is/can be so I'll refrain from commenting on it too much other than to say if the punishment, as laid out in the rules of the game, state that it should result in a ban then he should have got one. If not, Brown shouldn't be bleating about it.
As to the O'Loughlin tackle, there was no case to answer. There was no high tackle, it was fractionally late but, as many have said (Wigan fans, other teams supporters and ultimately the judiciary panel) he was entitled to make contact as he was already commited to the tackle. The only 'admonishment', if you can call it that, that he received was because his shoulder made contact with Robinson's head. Given that he is 5'7" and O'Loughlin over 6', that's hardly surprising! Both his hands in the challenge impacted on Robinson's chest. It was a legitimate challenge that could have, in the opinion of the panel, had a little more care taken. Nothing more. Brown is bleating about 2 month bans for something that is part of the game. No malice. No attempt to injure a player. Nothing. Just a slightly late legitimate challenge.
Now, Giants hat off for a moment, is his reaction that of a hypocritical, whinging coach who has a history of bleating about something whilst at the same time sanctioning genuine violence from his own players or not?