Very harsh

I don't think there will be much negativity untill the new season starts if we have some poor early losses which I don't think we will, I can see us having a great start and I really fancy playing Leeds in the first few games so we can turn them over

Beyond harsh it's actually stupid, although young Rogue has a precedent for ill considered nonsense...

How is it? He's hardly 1st class when he's not even been 1st team coach. Don't let facts get in the way though.

Mini Rogues, Maguire has just been assistant coach in the team who has just won the NRL! Bellamy said that he played a massive role in the success of Melbourne for a few years, you can tell by the way Melbourne play that he is clearly doing something right as he was in charge of the backs! Not to mention that Wayne Bennett rates him as the next best coach! All this and you call him a second rate aussie



He has not fully made it yet but he is certainly not second rate, you say it like we have just picked any old random coach up from the outback!

You opinion that it might not work out is valid and I respect your opinion but I'm afraid that is utter bull, sir.

In your ill thought out logic, you fail to consider that every coach that becomes a first team coach has prior to their appointment learned their coaching ropes as an assistant or in a lower grade. Was Wayne Bennett 'second rate' until he coached a first team? You may have just used poor English to illustrate that he is unproven as a first team coach, but knowing the s[ihi[/ite you talk regularly I'm not prepared to give you the benefit of the doubt

We'll have to wait and see and give him time, I hope it works but alot of people said the same about Lammy in why we can't take him on as coach so why not this guy?

A truly bizarre post from someone who doesn't appear to have a clue, and yet claims that he has facts.

People had doubts about Nobby after three and a half years of indifferent peformances. You have doubts about Maguire before he's even arrived!!!

Don't talk about facts. This is either personal agenda prejudice or plain idiocy.

Because he's been working at Melbourne with some of the best players in the world and Lammy hasn't? Melbourne's success is all down to Bellamy and Maguire don't you know.

If you can't see why Maguire is a better option than Lam then you need a visit to Lourdes!

View my post above!