Thats too tough!!! Im tempted to go for Dallas but I may just be looking back with Cherry n White tinted glasses!

I'll go for Paddy cos he can kick (we just need to win some silverware now)

Richards without a doubt.

Topping the points chart for a 3rd season in a row is justification enough. Although i would have loved them both in the same side.

IMO.. he was faster, more agile, a better finisher, could make a break from nothing and he has a similar rate to Richards even with playing outside Vaeliki for half of his time at Wigan.

Dallas every time assuming we remove the kicking from the equation. Dallas had a much better work ethic and was an electric finisher, but never got any ball, i think if Dallas had the same quality of service as Richards, his strike rate would be significantly higher.

Dallas for sheer speed...at his prime you knew when he made a break he would not be caught...just a more exciting winger to watch..but I do rate pat very highly.

It's like asking which is your favourite child

CC Semi in 2004 springs to mind. He pretty much won us that match with individual brilliance. 2 of his tries he was fast to react and his 3rd was sheer speed and awareness.

Dallas for me. Just because he is a proper winger.

However I still rate Pat very highly and we would of been lost without him for the last3 years.

Tough one that. If it was just down to being a winger Id take Dallas. As all round players you would have to go with Pat due to the points he gets us

Thats the issue.

Agreed