I think Mac has always asked us to judge him on team spirit and defence- Sadly today that had gone. I suspect he has lost the dressing room.

The first try of the game was a simple one on one(Wilkes the defender) who got handed of like a school kid. It then went downhill

When we were losing badly at half time why didn't he-
Move the 9 and 7 back to there real positions
Move Purdo to 13 thus having a decent 7, 9, 13 (cover centre with Bryan)
Give his 4th replacement a game of some form(he keeps using a 3 man bench)

I sometimes question his rugby intelligence- he seems very reactive in his decision making

He may well have lost the dressing room. At half time did you see Mac walking back to his seat with still about 5 minutes of half time left.

It will come as little surprise to regular readers of this forum that I completely agree with you.

How bad do things have to become before David Hughes does what's required and puts the club and, indeed, Brian McDermott himself out of this misery?

I know I've described Brian McDermott in the past as a 'miserable git'.

I retract this remark, which was made in haste and frustration. I accept that, while Brian McDermott is constantly miserable (with the press, with fans, with players, etc), he can't be described as a 'git'. That's unfair and inappropriate, and I apologise to him unreservedly.

However, it would be great if Brian felt moved to 'fall on his sword' and move on to another club. This would give him the benefits of a fresh start, thereby ditching the baggage of his negative impact on Quins RL.

It's just so painful to see him constantly failing catastrophically to select, coach and motivate talented players.

Unless Brian McDermott moves on, I think the end result for Quins RL is as predicable as it was when I first raised this point - falling crowds, catastrophic results and dwindling fan support.

The evidence is there for anyone who is open-minded enough to evaluate it for themselves.

I hate to come across as a Cassandra whose comments no one wants to hear, but reality speaks for itself.

Mac has to go.

If this thread is a fair reflection, at least your fans seem to have more sense than most. Scant consolation, I'm sure.

You need a better (more expensive) squad to draw in crowds and better crowds to afford that squad, so it is Catch-22.
I'm usually all in favour of prudence, and growing your own team, but perhaps a couple of big name signings would be worth gambling on? Generate a bit of excitement and maybe go some way to paying for themselves. I think the franchise needs something to kickstart it.

Would you believe it is £1.56 Million

About a year ago....

Really?!

I guess London is a dramatically more expensive place to live than, say, Hull or St. Helens.

Perhaps you should have London-weighting on the Salary Cap, although the money would still have to come from somewhere, of course.

I'd have thought it'd be mitigated by London being a dramatically more attractive place to live than, say, Hull or St. Helens - especially for antipodeans. Mind, I suppose there'll be a relocation premium for Northerners - if you live in West Yorkshire, you can easily change clubs without the hassle of upping sticks for a 1 or 2 year deal.

I used to be a season ticket holder at the Stoop first time round who drifted away gradually due to family and home changes but I went along today as my 13 year old son got an invite to the juniors event. Just after half time he turned to me and said he wished we hadn't bothered coming as Quins were so bad......next time there is a junior event I doubt he will bother to tell me or ask to go
What the answer to this is I don't know but I do fear for the future of SL in London ( And yes I know I am partly to blame by not attending like I used to).

IF THAT IS ACCURATE THEN IT'S NOT JUST MAC THAT NEEDS TO GO.

very good posting and very measured thoughts, and i agree with virtually everything that has been said

The squad is threadbare, what "stars" do we have?
danny orr is at the back end of his career really lets be honest (although i would not want to be without him this year)
Purds shows class, but needs support
I still think blaming mac for all our woes is pretty short sighted, the coach does not train players to kick the ball out on the full at kick off! he does not train the players to get caught offside at a goal line drop out
one of our best players on the park today is a relative newcomer to Rugby league

the core problem at the moment is finance!!!
it cant be denided we need a couple if not 3 BIG names

I don't think anyone is blaming BMcD for all our woes but our record over the second half of last season and first part of this has been diabolical. He has admitted he is clueless and the team don't seem to want to play for him.

Who picks the team, who decides which players to bring into the squad? The coach. If the players are not good enough they should be dropped and made to further develop their skills. Granted we cannot change the team but is it really different to the beginning of last season before we collapsed? That wasn't about money just poor decision making and dare I say coaching out individual skill sets. This is Mac's team and he has to go, another voice as coach may just have a different reaction to what we see now which is total rubbish. To keep on the present path will lead to no SL team in London. Once out of SL it will be at least 3 years and I suspect many more before we see top class league in London on a regular basis.

daft dad

ok lets drop some of the players who are not performing
lets say drop Clubby, danny orr, LMS
who would you suggest we play in there place!????

WE DO NOT HAVE THE SQUAD TO REALLY COMPETE, thats down to money

Jones, Kaye, May, Smith, Williams - on today's showing they couldn't be worse.