Really interesting to read your account of this afternoons game 'mickyb1234'

I was unable to attend the match this afternoon, this being only the third game I've missed all season.

So can you please tell me your views on the Salford City Reds players and I'm sure you will give me an honest reply just like your honesty about your own outfit.

Cheers JR

Is Will Sharp fully fit? I thought he looked to be running in a slightly laboured style when he tried to hit full pace today. I have a suspicion he may have played with something which hindered his movement today.

Not trying to make excuses. All in all it was a pretty dire day but it may explain why Will looked slower than he has on previous occasions.

Overall mate,

Not the best performance i seen from yr lot either! Big difference I think was a desire to win
You obviously have some speed merchants and i dont just mean Wilshire

noticable players today
Paul was distributing the ball pretty well
littler not as busy as he usually is, or not from what i saw anyhow
sibbit was noticable in the middle

Think it was McGilvray scored the intercept, he looked dangerous all game and was surprised a few more of the kick chases he got offered did not pay dividends, probably my stand out player for your lot

the LMS try through the middle was a massive hole, and did expose a weakness for you, that KR could well exploit
We got ripped apart on the wings by Bradford, your wing defence looked strong enough to me

Thanks 'mickyb1234'

As he seems to spend most of the game running the ball up like a forward for most of the game it is hardly surpring that he is looking kna..red

At least he gave chase, unlike many others.


Maybe its because he is tired with his workload of six players. It seemed that 33% of the time we were in possession Will Sharp had the ball.

More concerning was how we made a total mess of scoring after the break. Almost every team above us would have turned it into a try, maybe that's why they are above us...

I have to agree with you that there is far too much running sideways by most of the players. The forwards in particular cant run onto the ball beacause they have to hold back because there is no space for them to run into. This is something the coaching staff must be telling them to do because so many players are doing it.
Much as I admire Purdo he is not the sort of captain who gets the team going or is a general on the pitch. These players need someone to tell them what to do.
I dont believe the players don't care - i just think they havnt got the energy to do what they are being asked. Maybe we peaked early on in the season and now the tank is empty. Yes we dont have a lot of depth but the retaining of Jonny Grayshon, the signing of Mick Nannyn and Gardner had us all shaking our heads but these were BMs decisions. Are these really the best that BM could come up with.
I would add Wells to that list of names. How can a seasoned professional winger allow himself to be bundled into touch like that when we are trying to build up some pressure with tackles still in hand. The guy has no speed anymore, doesnt break a tackle, and has completely forgotton where the try line is. As ive said before, being a 'solid' full back isnt enough. The club should stick O'Callaghan in now for the rest of the season. We need tries - and someone with pace.

I will post further later but Alibert only made 1 error today, and that was not awarding a knockon late in the second half when Smith(?) was writhing at the play the ball and played it backwards for Alker who clearly fumbled. Otherwise he was spot in my eyes. Why people were crying when he awarded Salford the ball when it was a clear knock on from a high kick I will never know. I was right in front of it and it was a clear knock on from Quins.

I agree that will did at least give chase
and i dont deny that he does a stack load of work especially first and second tackle coming out of our red zone!
But it still is a worry that he could not go the full length with the start he had , it was the fact that there was at least 5 players catching him!!!

The comment about JW yep he is coming to the end of his life in the top flight as such, but bit like Will S he grafts all game
I have no prob with a winger getting taken in to touch now and again
What worries me is when people like Luke Dorn does one of his looping runs and then gets bundled like he did against the bulls

Maybe the training regime is wrong
Maybe the attitude in the camp is wrong
there is certainly a problem with fatigue with all the squad
maybe 1 year we can peak at the right end of the season

That was Curtis. Shame for him because I agree that otherwise he was one of the few bright spots.




Just one example. Curtis made an excellent break in the 2nd half. No support at all except for Gafa who, to his credit got there, but then lost the ball. I looked at the rest of the team - they were just strolling up the pitch. No urgency, no enthusiam, no effort!

And what was Dorn thinking about when he slipped that tricky inside pass to McGilvray? Didn't look, just tried to be clever.

I don't want this squad to scrape into the play-offs, it would be pointless.

I thought he was weak on Salford's offsides close to their own line.

You are so right with both of those Lister. There was hardly a grumble from our supporters about Alker's knock-on, yet all around me people were screaming at the ref although Wells clearly knocked on.

(I got a new pair of specs yesterday, BTW. )

The Dorn break and dropped pass, from what was a pretty poor pass really summed things up really
Whay not take the tackle, and build pressure, it was a panic last pass, could not really blame Gaffa for dropping it, but he did have a marker all over him so keeping hold and building would have been beter option!
BUT thats easy enough for me to say sat in the stands

The scary thing with the kick off out on the full for the penalty after Salford scored I wish i could have put a tenner on it
I said it would happen as we lined up the kick!! its what we do!!!!! and ever so predictable
On that front
why oh why do we not vary the kick off now and again?????

I do agree though I dont think i really want to go in to the play offs with the way we are playing

I know I've only been watching London rugby since 2002, but seriously the last 2 months - and the last fortnight in particular - have got to be the most depressing period I've experienced. At least in the seasons the Broncos flirted with relegation you knew the players just weren't competitive, and you got a sense they really, really tried hard and grafted with their limited means. What are the positives now? Nothing, nada, nowt. No heart, no passion, no resilience, no common sense... no optimism for the future.

Quite how I feel also. People are whining about sitting in the wrong stand and using that as their reason for not getting a season ticket. If things continue as they are, and McDermott is still coach, I probably won't bother either and I would suggest that my reasoning for making such a decision would not be uncommon, and certainally a more important concern for the club over those who don't like the view.

Is Luke Dorn contracted for next year? What an utter shambles. Threw a silly interception, a lovely hospital pass to Gafa after a break up field, woeful kicking game as usual (theres no point in doing a cross kick if nobody is following). I await someone telling me what a brilliant try he scored but a 16 year old should be able to take advantage of a 4 vs 2 situation.

Make LMS captain and build the team around him, he and a select band of others are the only ones that care. Lamont and Clubb also I would suggest.

I have been one of Wells' biggest supporters and defended him for ages but he's been very poor in recent weeks, basic errors - people say he should be playing full back, but I don't think this is good enough. He clearly is not fast enough to play on the wing anymore, all he does is cut inside because he isn't fast enough to beat the man on the outside.

What happened to Ward? Why was Haggerty determined to get himself sent off?

A serious clear out is needed at the end of the season. Players who are not good enough IMO (forgetting contracts for now):

Gafa
Wells
Dorn
Gardner
Heckenberg
Williamson

Sharp needs to seriously buck his ideas up too.

We need a decent half back, a utility back and a better hooker than Kaye who has been shown up recently IMO.