Alibert should consult with his touch judge before putting a scrum down. And I'm not convinced it was the touch judges call either.

There have been forward passes aplenty for both sides.

Can't disagree with your last point.

3 forward passes ignored so far this half. Kearney's pass to Hargreaves in the build up to the try was a yard forward

Knock on by Leuluai?!

Ah Van tackled?

Nothing to provoke 3 laughing smilies Listy

Xenophobe

It's amusing because our fans seem to moan every week at the referee, when really he didn't have a bad game. If the part timer had put in a performance like Alibert, a so called full time referee, did last night, I could understand.

I have no problem with the refs performances generally as they only ref what they see. Touch judges do not help them most of the time. But could write a book of biblical proportions on Mistress Ganson's utter incompetance

What was the penalty count? He didn't half spank Catalans and thats without the constant off sides!

I said to Thaler after the game "we cant even blame you!"