What it probably shows is there was a mistake.

Yeah and mistakes are going to be made until every game it televised and we have the bunker like nrl
So where was he stood anyone looked

Find it yourself if you are so obsessed.

Hey am not obsessed simply asking the question, you could try reading my post I said I cant find it on u tube.
The suggestion was all the other officials apart from ref thought it was a try. So simply asking where did tj go? That will tell you if he thought it was a try.

come on everyone stop winding Northernbloke up. We all know he thinks ref's are perfection personified

Now now, get yr facts right, I have always said that they can and do make mistakes.
But the statement on here was that everyone thought it was a try including the in goal, am merely trying to educate, as in where was TJ that will tell you what he thought. And in goal actyally agreed with the ref, so that's 3 that didnt see it as a try

As i was the one who mentioned it in a earlier post. I thought i should say i looked back on you tube when you said you couldn't find it. And you are right, i found the hudds highlights and the disputed try at the end has been cut from the highlights so I'm unable to confirm what I saw before
But I do remember others commenting at the time including I think some hudds fans to saying we were unlucky

NB the ref we have for Thursday is the ref that put the opposition on a team warning then didn't sin bin the next offender for an 'attacking' penalty 2 minutes later, when he reffed us last time. I sent him a twitter msg asking for an explanation of the law but got nothing as you would expect.

I hope not to notice the ref.

I hope you boys stay up......just not at our expense.

Which ever team loses tomorrow - there's still plenty of games left to play and Leeds and Wakeys run in looks more difficult than either of ours.

Exiled
And quite rightly so, ref put team on a team warning for several offences in the defensive line, they then offended while in attack, that does not result in a yellow, had they then committed another offence in the defensive line while still under the warning it would have been a yellow.
In that case he did the correct thing

Alan, thanks for looking!

So you've seen it now have you? Given you now quote the in goal agreed with the ref. Grateful if you could share a link.

read my thread traffic I asked where the tj was stood.
I didnt need to see the replay to know what the in goal decision was.

Again what have you seen that leads you to say three people (TJ, in touch and ref) all thought it was no try? The post I commented on ends with you stating that, so how did you come to that conclusion?