Agree with a three year contract for Ellis, he's doing really well. Purdo is an obvious for a new contract offer. Give Williams the elbow - he's out of his depth in Super League. Wilkes, Ward and Melling should also get new contract offers.

At the risk of being the club apologist again to some people remember we have to have a certain number of club trained in the squad (unlike it seems HKA)! I thought Dave Williams had his best game last week - I beleive they say props aren't at their best until about 26 - 28.

Agree with that extent Paddock, but wouldn't mindseeing Ben Hodgson getting a squad number next year in as a home grown replacement.

Think we should be looking for a younger, faster front row next season, which is why I'd release Ward and Temata. As for Randall, I don't think he's been the same since we played Hull KA away in 09, and that's why I'd look for change in the halves. Wouldn't mind seeing an unpredictable 7 coming in, a bit like a Rangi Chase or even a Brough-like, 'cause I think we've been predictable so far this season on the last tackle and especially our kicking game.

As for Melling, I'm not sure where he'd fit. Unless we kept him as a backup LF, I don't think he's a SR and I don't think he's the best winger at the club.

Who would you suggest to replace Ward and Temata, who are doing perfectly well at the momment?

New players in. Temata would free up an overseas place, so would look for a Pacific Islander NRL player, a big beast-like player that I think we're missing. I'd replace Ward with Krasniqi and bring in Ambler on a permanent deal.

Krasniqi as our starting prop? Are you serious? In partnership with Ambler? We'd be hammered every week.

Nope, off the bench. Wilkes and a new signing would be my choice of starting props. I doubt we'd be hammered every week if Krasniqi played, I mean we've lost 82-6 and 52-32 without him in the team.

Pimkerton - I have liked the look of Ben Hodgson when I have seen him