Quins RL games seen by GF this season......... 0

Listy...I do not agree with his stance on the Union tie in or the employment of australians in place of locally developed players, but the question is worth asking.

A coach can be judged on many things, but results and trophies are what they are remembered for.....and Brian McDermott....and I may stand corrected here, is the London Superleague Teams worst performing coach on record.
Tony Currie, Dan Stains, Tony Rea & Les Kiss, John Monie, Tony Rea and now Mac...........John Monie went after a bad season, Stains took the team as far as he could...but the current coach has had 3 years EXACTLY (July 8th 2006).......and has presided over 109 SL games in that time.
W 42
L 64
D 3

Broken down.
2006 W 5/L 4 Finished 7th
2007 W10/D3/L14 Finished 9th
2008 W 1/L16 Finished 9th
2009 W 1/L16 Finished 11th
2010 W 5/L14 currently 13th..........

38% win ratio....no cup run to speak of, no hope of anything this year other than a worse Win Loss ratio and possible the lowest place finish in the history of Superleague. Not even the argument that we have a bad squad stands up....we are told we are nearly at cap FFS.........

Listy, you blame the players all you like. Mac was an assistant coach at Leeds before he came south.....he has proved he is assistant coach standard whilst he has been in charge......we briefly flattered to deceive in early 2009....but the wheels came off and we have not maanaged to improve since.....and it is his responsibility...the same way it is PB's responsibility to get more revenue for the club through more fans......like it or not, he has to go and be replaced by a coach with a better tactical understanding of the game.

Sorry....wrong. I have managed to catch the live sky games.....but I have also read the reports, listened to his excuses/musings in how to take positives from every game and looked at the SL table.....we are crap and it is the coaches fault.....If I remove this years games from the above statistics.......he had a 41% win ratio before this year...he's getting worse



Tony Rea....first 90 games in sole charge had the following record.

L45/W41 D4........45% WIN Ratio....so with Tony Rea in charge, we had an 18% better chance of winning. Not sure is anyone else can come up with the win ratios for the other London coaches in SL, but I am sure Macs 38% from 90 games will be hard to beat.

To be fair, Rea was in charge up until July 2006 and as far as I can find out, coached London in 162 SL matches with 67 wins, 8 draws and 87 losses. 41% win ratio with 2004 dragging his average down (strange year that...sandwiched between 2 play-off finishes?).....brings back memories of how depressed we all were when the pies nicked Moran.......and preceeded to ruin him



Listy............Tony Rea......from 2000 to 2006 found us some stars...players I will always consider London players..regardless of where they went afterwards.....
Paul Sykes (Holds the club goal kicking record in a SL game)
Please enjoy...Nigel Roy...always gave 100%
Denis Moran..twice leading SL try scorer.....and a nice guy with it
Robert Purdham (need I expand)....
Tony Martin....kicked goals for fun and chipped in with some important tries
Rusty Bawden.....one of the main reasons the club sold VB at Griffin Park
Ritchie Barnett....best full back I saw play for us.
Mark McLinden, Luke Dorn (first spell) Joe Mbu (never seen a harder working player...he's be a legend if he had talent).......I even think our best performing forward of 2009 and 2010 so far, Karl Temata was a Rea find......and I could go on...the list would be quite impressive when naming GOOD players that came to the club when Rea was in charge.........please.....let's have a list of the players that Mac has brought to the club who you would class as having fond memoriies of or even performed when here?
Short list methinx!

First of all why use personal insults simply because I hold different viewpoints and secondly I hope you'll be happy when your blind cheerleading results in the club failing to win a Superleague franchise.

Oh no-I had built my hopes up that he would be off. The decision is made it would appear so lets move forward and get on with things.

Wellsy was talking him up on B n A last night

Cheers!

Looks like those Bulls who listened to it formed same view - and were impressed with the programme generally too.

Bit surprised at the language used elsewhere on this thread, by someone charged with dealing with that if used by others?

At least we know now then.
I look forward to the final flourish next season.

I thought the time difference between NZ and England was 12 hours, not 12 months!

Yeah and we spent millions of £ that we didn't have and we went bust when we brought those blokes in. We cannot afford to spend money on such players anymore, and the quota rules are far tighter than they used to be. Rea also brought in plenty of shocking players, but because he had the opportunity to bring in more Australians than is allowed now, some were bound to be successes.

Oh well, Co-Op Premiership it is, then. What I find really disturbing is that I keep agreeing with Gutters on all this.

Because you crawl out from under your stone and add nothing to these forums. With regards to your second point, you really are clueless if you believe that I will do that.

All we get off gutterfax is a completely objective view of the situation. He can draw on statistics all he likes, but I will keep saying it, McDermott is not the reason we have lost games this season.