A number of us saw Eden get the ball down, Paea was the defender? Looking at the highlights it did look like Eden got it down, Nathan Brown said after the game on Sky that it was a try and if the ref had the option of video replay it would have been given - C'est la vie as they say in French

i thought eden had clearly grounded it too but haven't seen the replays yet.
and how come leon pryce always scores against us?

unfortunately not all those little dragons were well behaved, there were some throwing leftover sandwiches, and chewing gum, one kid abot 10 yrs old sat right at the back, skulker hit a woman on the back of the head with a bottle, fortunately it was plastic and empty, or could have been nasty. Any Catalan supporters reading this please take note.

Yes gum and chewed up food thrown-and two fingered gestures-there doesn't seem to be anyone in charge of them!

did anyone else manage to get hold of some leftover sarnies after the game?
there were one or two unruly kids yes,but the vast majority were well behaved and were high fiving us after the game and shouting 'merci' at us.

I thought that the majority of the kids were well behaved as well and actually, I quite enjoyed sitting amongst them. They certainly added to the atmosphere and it was good to see so many young people being so passionate about the game - the Giants are missing a trick here.

However, there will always be bad apples and unfortunately I was appalled by some the behaviour of a couple of Giants fans.

Firstly, there was a guy on our CST bus from the city to the stadium who was unecessarily abusive and threatening towards David Foti. He'd obviously had more than a skinful and was unhappy with something that David had previously told him, but if he reads this forum, now that you have sobered up, do you maybe think that there was a reason he didn't want you on his bus?? You were an embarrassment to yourself, to the Giants, to Huddersfield in general but more importantly, you were intimidating towards my family and other supporters on the bus - it's not on.

It was also obvious that he and a couple of others on the bus were part of the so-called 'singing section' and the songs being sang on the bus were, how shall I say this, not appropriate when families are present. In fact, I don't think that they were appropriate at all. Just because nobody else wanted to join in with you, doesn't warrant the abuse. We were vocal when it counted - in the stands.

The subject of the singing section gets brought up quite regularly on here with regular invites to go and join them. Well,from what I saw on Saturday, it may be that a couple of truly unpleasant people are keeping folk away. I'll certainly be staying where I am thanks. But before anybody jumps down my throat, I don't have an issue with the majority and had a good craic with some of you on Saturday, but unfortunately, you know what they say about them bad apples I mentioned before...

I know who u are referring to and yes he was bang out of order and i told him that and apologised to dave foti on our behalf,i agree about the singing,im one of the vocal fans but didnt think those songs were appropriate on the bus and did tell them to save it for the bar/at the ground.he later apologised to me saying he was out of order but doesn't change the fact that he gave himself and us a bad name.
And he is very vocal but not part of our singing section in the kilner bank, your welcome to join us at the back,anyone who steps outta line gets pulled up for it.
Hope u enjoyed your trip despite this?

He asked me, if i new the times of the public buses and i said no (as i dont) but pointed him to the bus timetable, then he started abusing me saying YES YOU DO, BUT YOU DONT WANT TO TELL ME .

Then after deciding to jump on our bus, he started again and didnt believe me, when i told him, that this was a private bus booked by CST , i could have decided not to let him on , but i knew it would have blown up and police called .lol , what an attitude problem.

cheers
Dave

Oh dear, a case of "Beer in brains out"

As my late father used to say "If you can't hold your ale, dont drink it"
Can't understand people wanting to argue/fight after a few pints, all I want to do is go to sleep.

he was out of order with you, apparently you told him the number 2 bus went to the ground, but when he asked the number 2 driver he said he didnt,he then decided he was gonna take it out on you! i was the one who apologised for his behaviour.
believe it or not he's not a bad bloke, just dont think the perpignan pints agreed with him

We let in a couple of tries close to the ruck on our own goal line which is not something we have come to expect this year.Nathan - not unsurprisingly - has mentioned this,is not happy about it and despite all the good fringe defence of this year already pinpointed he wants that sorted.

Our right edge defence is always going to get targeted,to me a lot depends if they have got their defensive heads on,they love to attack and are brilliant at that,but on occasions it seems they stop communicating on defence and then when the break is made against them they just give up too quick on the scramble and look to start blaming each other.

If the 'Billy Slater' try was awarded as it may have should been,we could have come away from Perpi with the two comp points,so not discouraged at all.

Suppose there is the slight doubt if we are dropping off the fringe defence with Wigoon coming up.Not worried about the Broncos though even if our fringe d is gash,into the semi we will go.

If the songs weren't appropriate for the bus then what makes them appropriate for the bar/ground?

I meant appropriate as in the people on the bus didnt want to sing i didnt mean the wordings of the songs,even then a couple that were sung wouldn't have been appropriate anywhere.
In the ground or at the bar people will join in but on the bus they felt intimidated and to abuse people for not joining in was out of order.

Yeh cool Meast thanks.
Probably just got him on a bad day
Maybe he was reading the match review before they played lol

all over now

cheers
Dave

just seen the highlights..

good try from ferguson... one of the catalans tries was poor defence from grix but he made up for it with a try later on

and that run from chan was awesome...got to be up there for try of the season!