Watched the game on Sky when I got in after going to the game. What's your thoughts on Eddie shouting "Oh Nooooo when Grix scored at the end?

Was at the game so difficult to see the ball strip by Briers with 6 to go, Silverwood said play on but the lino gave the knock on, at the game you have to accept it as from behind the sticks you don't get a good view.

I did watch the last 10 mins back when I got in, too late to watch the whole game, and the lino got it wrong, there's 2 in the tackle and Briers rips the ball, so we got a bad call in a crucial point in the game, had we got the penalty we'd be camped on your line with 6 mins and 2 points a drift so who knows.

I haven't watched the bit where Grix scored as I haven't watched all the game back, may do over the weekend, but what Eddie says has nothing to do with the Giants, so having a go at us seems a little out of order to be honest.

You get bad calls in games, we have to live with it, be interesting how you react if the opposite happens to you in the final and the opposition go on and win.

Anyway good luck next week, and see you all in 2014.

It's been poor from most officials all season, they need to clean it up for next year.

last week against hull we got the 50/50 calls, last night we didnt , best team won on the night as they scored more points...well done wire

I wouldn't expect the Huddersfield fans to have an issue with Silverwood until you watch the game back on Sky. It would have been too difficult to see from your position in the ground.

I thought Silverwood was particularly poor, the big decisions seemed to go Warrington's way. Penalising Connor for a strip when he had the ball over Atkins on the floor, penalising Ferguson for a high shot but allowing Morley's and Westwoods, blatant offside of Richie Myler after Danny Brough's break and the ball strip by Briers.

I still Warrington deserved to edge it, just, but Huddersfield had some momentum going into that final 10 and the ref ruined it from a neutrals perspective.

I think it was Cudjoe making a mess of clearing up that prompted him to shout that rather than Warrington scoring.

Perhaps he was disappointed that we weren't going to get a tense, exciting last 5 mins - the kind of climax to a game that commentators thrive on?

That was my thought. Everyone will have their own opinion that suits their agenda though.

You would think that.... unless the commentary team had spent the last eighty minutes willing Huddersfield to win. After we had won all they could talk about was how good Huddersfield were. Bizarre.

And from both being at the game and watching it back through I can safety say the referee made not on jot of a difference to the end result. Nothing controversial at all.

Aw bless the poor little mites, not getting the attention they deserve!!

was a very crucial call that one where murphy had the ball stripped, we were on a roll and that would of put us on the wire line...

morley seemed to get away with a fairbit lastnight too

Didn't think he was too bad at the time but having watched the game back there is certainly one or two things that went against us, mainly consistency in the interpretations by Silverwood. whether it will have made the outcome any different no-one will ever know.

as I posted on another thread

bridge and morley get away with swinging arms/high shot, we get a penalty against and a man on report for same thing..,both decisions in favour of warrington



westwood twice going into the tackle/PTB with knees, one resulted in a knock on against us, another, no action taken.decisions favouring warrington.



briers ball strip on murphy, led to a knock on against us and led to the winning try.decision in favour of warrington.



on 2/3 occasions, silverwood calls held then release, warrington player then carries on with the tackle, puts the man to ground and turns him over, decision in favour of warrington ( we conceded 4 penalties for lesser infringement), decisions in favour of warrington.



ball steal ruling against jake connor when the ball was there to be won, decision favoured warrington.



various occasions wire got away with things that we got penalised for, like I said, that's my opinion on the ones I can remember.

I am in no way claiming these decisions changed the outcome of the game, just pointing out that IMO warrington got just about every decision go their way.

that's how I saw it after watching the game back, im not saying the result would have been different as we still made too many crucial errors in defence and attack but warrington definitely got the decisions last night.

but its done with now and they are in the final and good luck to them

OMG meast you've gone and done it now, WF3 going to thing Christmas has come early, thought we'd finally got shot of him, bugger..

perhaps wire werent penalised when they should have been. From what I can see we were penalised when we should have been - ATEOTD if we are penalised for indiscretions then we have ourselves to blame noone else.