would you be expected to retire if you got injured and couldn't work for a period?

Totally different. All 3 are done in regards to their rugby careers. They need to start their post rugby careers now. Until these lot move on, along with a few others the club will struggle to progress.

All 3 are 31 if they wanted they have another 3 years in them , I don’t see why you always seem to hate on these 3 , uate hasn’t been given a chance to prove himself when fit , Leroy is one of the most passionate players I’ve ever seen in a giants shirt I have no doubt he wants to pull on the shirt again to help us out more then most and fergie maybe his time has come with this bad injury could do more harm playing on but last year was one our better players

How many 34 year old wingers do you see these days? Uate is 32 soon. He was crocked when we signed him, just like Mamo. Massive gamble on a player past it and injured and its backfired.

Leroy has played hardly any games in 2 year and looks like hes done for the year again now. Should pay him off like we did Eorl and give him a coaching role.

We as a club have been poor for too long and if that means becoming a bit ruthless then so be it. Otherwise well have 3 big earners sat on sidelines again next year and well be in the same position we are in now.

Same age as Jerry , hall both still playing good rugby not to the standard they were couple of year ago but still good rugby , you’ve wrote him off before he’s even had the chance to show us what he can do , if when he comes back and he’s awful then find but you’ve got to give him a chance

I’d like to watch Jerry Hall playing

He’s had a chance and been awful. I don’t buy the injury excuse a foot injury doesn’t stop you catching a ball!

agree, got to give uate a chance to play when hes 100% fit, clearly he wasnt when he played earlier in the season but he put his hand up to play because we were busted for players.

agree with cudjoe and ferguson has just been unlucky, in his come back at wakefield he already showed what he can do, feel for him.. hopefully he can get better with the problem he has and get the all clear to return to training.

id get shut of others before these 3 all day long

A massive game for both Huddersfield and Leeds. Both sides will see it as a game they should win, with the loser in real danger of relegation. Looking forward to this game.

So you think being 100% fit will mean he can suddenly catch??

He was never the greatest at catching when he was in the Nrl but was still a good player, he’s a powerful winger who can make yards and score tries.
I am curious why you are all so positive to write him off without seeing him really play

What do you mean without really seeing him play. He’s played 12 games.
How does he get the ball in his hands to score those tries he scored? I’m not just on about high balls- he’s dropped quite a few decent passes out too.