sorry!!!

To be fair we were missing a number of key players - Brough, Mcgillvary, Leroy, Mamo, Leeming, Roberts. Any team struggles without their key players.

Nope you are wrong. Ken Davy, Richard thewlis and three successive coaches say that - not me.

Ok jools you are right as usual, sorry, thewlis is not an issue it was sharp then brown then Anderson then Stone now thorman, spot on

So not ken Davy then?

You forgot mall Reilly, van de velde, John kear ... oh wait Richard wasn’t even MD at the club then.....

Ken Davy is allowing the slide, how he can be happy with thewlis is mind boggling, so many big decisions wrong for so long, but hey you keep believing in him I for one have had enough

It’s not just the quality of the first team that’s sliding.

Losing to a side as hopeless as Catalan shows not everything was the fault of Rick Stone. He's gone and things are not exactly improving as Giants fans said would happen when he was handed his p45.

The supporters got behind them Friday because they played with some determination and guts when clearly on paper their pedigree was nowhere near the Rhinos

Today was a disgrace and a betrayal of fans who spent their earnings travelling out there to support hoping for at least a repeat showing that would get them up to 8th position after a poor start . The senior players showed no leadership and example to the young lads thrown to a team made up mainly of seasoned pros and looked to have absolutely no rhythm or game plan .

At least someone should have introduced them to each other before they got on the plane
What a complete waste of a pilots time and fuel!

Frankly the horizon of hope looks a very long way away Forget the injury justification Professional players paid to do their job should at least have some personal pride but no evidenceof it on that showing . Still Mac should at least be grateful !

Thewlis is an utter disaster no area of the club is moving forward on his watch and anyone who thought appointing Thorman and keeping the same cosy set up was the way forward had a rude awakening today. Only Ken knows why he continues to put his trust in someone who is not up to managing a professional club

What position do Thewlis and Thorman play? The way I see it they would not have played as bad as the team who played at the Catalans.

It’s not about 1 result or performance it’s the structure and ethos of the whole set up that needs changing.