Eorl out,big blow,not as good as he was now but knows the only way is forward.

Roberts,good lad,good go forward,got to start working harder out of marker.

Symonds return would be huge boost.

yeh crabtree being out is a miss

but he does nothing right according to some fans who just moan when he gets the ball

good to have symonds and wood back who have been going well for us as has roberts

jury is still out on ikahihifo for me, looked awesome first 2 games but not since, what is he a prop? a second rower?!

Ikahihifo is the same as the rest of them, out of confidence, out of shape and almost out of super league.
Most of them are looking like poor players at the moment, the team is awful so naturally most of the individuals in that team are struggling.

out of shape, do you agree that we should get a new conditioning team in place then?

It appears something is wrong in that department yes!
i stood behind the posts last week when Leigh were waiting to receive a kick off, and some of their lads, Weston, Hansen, Brown all looked toned and lean, but some of our lot were looking extremely flabby by comparison.
However Mr. Stone assured us he is working on this "problem".

Sorry but he's been here long enough to have been able to make a start on fitness but nothing seems to have changed. Don't know if that clown who came from U16 football level fitness is still at the club or not but he should have been sent packing on day 1 and somebody who knew what they were doing brought in.
It doesn't take much to sort out at least the nutrition/diet of the players.

Are you for real! He's beem here 6 weeks- how long do you imagine it takes to get someone fit! bearing in mind he can't flog them as they still need to be able to go out and play 80 against other professional players...

But that's not at the end of the season which was implied.

I imagine most people at the club are under contract, I imagine Rick Stone can't just terminate contracts of people already under contract?
Again, i fail to see how a coach who has been here for a few weeks can change things that have/ had gone wrong over a year or 2 ?

totally comitted to the giants cause eh

He has signed for 2018, yes, but how do any of us know whether he is committed or not?

Again, guesswork and presumptions.

Pretty shrewd guesswork based on the crap he has shown this season

Actually yes I am for real. Believe me, I do know a little bit about fitness levels, nutrition diet etc therefore in a 6 week period there could have been things put in place to improve these issues. Also, believe me, these have not been addressed as of yet and nothing has changed.