And what I am suggesting is that whether the players around him are playing well or not he is not a top class half back.

Tend to agree with Marsdengiant on this one.
He was playing with the Invisible Man against Saints - some shocking passing. Can't blame anyone else for those.
However, his effort can't be questioned and I sincerely hope he stuffs my comments down my throat on Friday.

Totally agree. he is a big hearted player who always gives it a go.

Watching the highlights last night, and I think there were a lot of culprits for wayward passing, Robbo shouldnt be singled out.

More importantly, how long was Crabtree stood waiting to offload when he broke through close to their line?

Any longer he would have had pidgeons sat on his head but no support whatsoever.

Yes really.

Having seen him play a few times and seen the things he is capable of I think Brown will help him to develop and utilse his skills. we have seen ball players with good base skills like Moore /Lunt /Brown come on leaps and bounds under NB.

Clearly in the mass exodus of your 1st teamers he is one you are happy to see go...so be it.

No, would quite like to keep him, but as a squad player that can cover a few positions. If it was the choice of having him at 6 for the full year or losing him then yes, happy to see him go.

Time will tell l suppose!

Simon Finnigan was on his shoulder waiting for him to pop a pass out. The support play was there but he just wasn't aware of it.

chocolate --and nuts inside!

Robinson = most overrated player in super league. I never really liked brown either, but he must have something, cos huddersfield look nowhere near the same team without him.

......but if you insist .................a group of fans voting on a 3-2-1` for each match have come up with the following :-

22 L.Robinson
16 B.Hodgson
15 S.Moore
14 K.Mason
12 E.Crabtree
12 D.Kirmond
11 A.Raleigh
9 D.Faiumu
9 S.Lunt
8 L.Cudjoe
8 L.Fulton
7 K.Brown
5 D.Hodgson
4 S.Wild
3 P.Whatuira
3 D.Sculthorpe

Not saying all will agree - but to pillory the lad wont do much good !

After all the club signed him to do the job and looking at the above - he cant be TOO badly, can he??

His trouble might just be he tries TOO hard -- but if others around dont -- is that really something to criticise
Like the initial comment -- some shouldnt carry knives!
Too quick to apportion blame I say! Get off his back - wont do any good -- he might try harder still!

...........and thank YOU for your kind thoughts --I wont bother with my contenders --too long a list!!