'no he is not good enough'. peter hood and Steve Mc Namara

He's now scored 18 tries in 10 games so far this season

18 in 10? Not bad going...

After he scored a bunch at Fev one of the Post Office Roaders text Radio Leeds complaining that 'all he does is score tries.' (As an aside, have Fev ever actually been beaten by the better team?) It *almost* doesn't matter what else he does if he can keep that record going!

Myler has made a positive impact in SL this season and I hope Gregg can do the same, the signs are certainly very promising.

Also, look how our signing from NL2, Shaun Lunt, has gone this season. Class act. And, for that matter, L Patrick, who we plucked out of nowhere and, after an early error had another decent game today.

Just got back from Haven, glad we won. Mcnally reminds me of Danny mcguire, doesn't look to be doing much but everytime haven break the line he's in support and generally scores.

IMO he's not ready for SL yet, he's probably too skinny, but with fulltime training and putting a bit of weight on you've got a very good player on your hands.

I'd agree with you - although look at how S Tomkins is playing and he's a beanpole.

Having watched Gregg today I disagree. I think he would slot into most SL teams without any problem. His ability to find a gap and support the runner is as good as I've seen for ages. He is far too good to be playing NL1 and 18 tries in 10 games suggests that.

having said that if you take McNally out of the Haven team you struggle to see where the points would come.

Slightly edited your post Wadski




If you can tell

Nice edit - Glad you changed the "J"

Did I put J? I thought I put J and I realised I meant S.

Good point. I wouln't expect Mcnally or Tomkins to put too much weight on as it probably would have a negative effect on their game, I think another stone would probably help though.

Feel free to call him back to the giants before the seasons finished too. As has been mentioned on this thread before Haven look poor when he's not playing. Talking to some Haven fans today they even say they're rubbish without him and will struggle next year.

he played for haven yesterday agianst halifax and halifax won the game 24-18. mcnally scored 3 tries and 3 kicks for haven and that means he scored all 18 point for them. never seen haven play but sounds like their gunna struggle next year when he comes to us

Looks like we will get a chance to watch him

Thu 7 Whitehaven v Widnes (7.30pm) 7.30pm Championship