He got 10 mins and never received a pass, waste of money imo

shot out of the line and gave them a try?

Him or Brough, i await the approriate thread

not been today but from the times I have seen him I'm not impressed at all. Might come good next season after a full pre season under his belt but I'm not convinced it will!!!!

It's obvious now that 6 will be his best position.

Played 8, scored 0.

Whether it is too early to judge him or not, he is not up to speed yet and my view is that the Knockout stages of the playoffs is not the time to try to get him to bed in.

Maybe one of those rare ones,a bad choice out of NRL.Small guy so doesn't look a fb or centre.

Stand off is where I would like to see him get a shot.

steady on guys, he came over here without a pre season, got thrown into the deep end so to speak and hasn't really had a set position.
i seem to remember pat richards,matt king and trent barrett didn't exactly set the world on fire when they first came, even finch this season came good after a dodgy start. judge him when he's settled into the side.

You have to wonder why he got picked today. Fooey was our bench hooker. Why not have Raleigh or Kirmond on the bench instead?

He got hardly any game time, he didn't see any ball at all. It was a puzzling choice IMO.

Talking of Fooey why was he pulled off for Larne early in the second half when we were into the arm wrestle,big mistake that.

If you didn't go today how can you possibly comment. The fact he didn't touch the ball is more down to poor play by the players who didn't pass to him. Three sets on leeds' line and Simpson opposite the smallest guy on the field- if Simpson had been given the ball he would have run over him to score but they kept trying to go through the middle against JJB, peacock and Bailey. Poor choices.

hey jools we agree on one the three sets at 20-24 was the game breaker and anyone who went couldn't blame JS as you rightly say he never had a chance....

We rarely score from twenty metres out- we are too obvious. Why not move eorl or Patrick out wide to run at the smaller guys. Today when we had all those sets on leeds line Burrow was defending out at centre, Simpson is twice the size and never got the ball. As a tactic send the likes of eorl, Patrick or fa'alogo running out wide close to the line against the smaller guys. We would have scored today if we did that.

read my post before having a go. I said from what I've seen of him I've not been impressed. Where did I say he played poor today as I can not comment as like I've said I wasn't there!!!!!