At last after 10 posts someone has got it right



As much as i like Grix he has not been tested defensively yet. His completeion rate for high kicks was 50% on Sunday.Attacking wise he offered everything Hodgson does. I am all for trying new things and i could understand Brown keeping some of his players in BUT Mc Gilvray and Grix would be up for a real defensive challenge against Tomkins kicks and Richards ball catching abilities.

Do we want to take a gamble i think both decisions are judgement calls. there is no right or wrong except with hindsight.

I would keep Mcgillivary in for the Wigan game but i have a feeling Nathan Brown will go with Lolesi for extra experience.

Yep I'd keep Bruno and Jerry in, they've both been playing well recently and its pointless dropping them for the sake of it - let them keep going and improving - as for Brett, difficult one as he is too good to not be playing but Grix has covered well for him so its a hard one to call really.

i think if lolesi is fit then he will drop Mcgillivary put leroy on the wing to cover richards height and then put lolesi in the centres then normal changes with our forwards returning and probs brett they say never change a winning team but against this wigan side i think some changes have to be made

I know hes new and raw! But McGillivary has impressed me when Ive watched him live! His work rate is good and he can defend! I would leave him in the side!!

dont get me wrong i like mcgillivary i think his a good young winger that will get better but we did the same thing against leeds we dropped mcgillivary im guessing as he lack of experience in big games so im guessing NB will just do the same againts wigan. i can see mcgillivary being a permanent winger next season but for this season i think he will stick with regular players against the bigger teams

I am still not convinced that Brough is a good player yet, however he played very well last week and in my eyes he should have got MOTM.

Mate you would not know a good player if one fell out of a cupboard and landed on your head.

I want him to get better and im giving him some praise but he still has a lot to prove. What like something that landed on your head

I'd not drop Brad out of the team, he has been absolutely superb these last few weeks, as has Brough, and it's looking like Broughy's coming good now, I would have Lolesi for David H, he's got more pace than him! (Actually, Earl has more pace

)