I don't think an NRL side will be, they hate players that are suspect defensively and sadly Mamo is one of those. He's made for the english game and the more broken style of play but he has shown up badly in the poorer conditions. I think if he were fit at the start of last year instead of making his debut when the ground had firmed up noone would have a good opinion of him.

For me id like to see us try line up like this when everyone is fit.

1. McIntosh
2. Jerry
3. Leroy
4. Murphy
5. Mamo
6. Turner
7. Brough
8. Seb
9. Leeming
10. Clough
11. Mellor
12. Lawrence
13. Hincliffe

14. Roberts
15. Taai
16. O Brien
17. Walne/English (Although Walne is a crock similar to Symonds)

There’s no way you can play McIntosh at FB. His catching is worth three tries a match to the opposition.

He did it again today, although the commentators were convinced it was Simpson.

The lad has to find a position in field or drop down the leagues I’m afraid.

Any SL halfback will take him apart.

Mamo is exactly the same though. He cost us tries against Hull,Wakefield and Saints due to knocking on, just before half time in 2 of the games. We need to give McIntosh an extended run for me and see how he goes. Mamo is fairly quick and im sure would finish quite a few tries on the wing and make many metres coming in also.

How many spiralling bombs did Mackintosh take perfectly against Leeds under pressure??? He was fantastic against Leeds- a young kid who’s not played for weeks and then plays two in three days and you get on his back!!! Think there a more senior players who you should be demanding be dropped first!

He dropped one- Mamo drops theee a game and can’t/won’t pass for toffee but he’s the messiah according to a large number of our clueless.
One tough ball dropped and you want him in the championship . Jeez!

There's some fickle people on here. McIntosh was superb at full back on Friday. Dealt with some very difficult balls. Had a poor game today and some have written him off. We need to be patient with the younger players, give them game time to enable them to develop.

Fans are going to turn on young players quick it’s not right but we ain’t saints Leeds or Wigan who can carry a few young lads having a good game 1 week and poor game next because we ain’t got the senior player to carry them the position we are in now we can’t afaid to bed in young players

Sadly, the club doesn’t have the time to be patient with younger players.

People wanted the structure changed to bring “jeopardy”. Fine, but the flip side of that is younger players don’t get the time to make mistakes. They need to perform. The middle eights are upon us sooner than you think

The system is crazy, but it’s what the fans want.

Spot on. Clubs at the bottom end of the table don’t get the luxury of bedding in young players.

Macintosh had a mare today, but he looked absolutely knackered, and clearly everything he did was affected by fatigue. Guess that's easter when you got a thin squad and most of them are injured. I personally would play rankin at full back seen as he sure as hell aint a halfback, mamo and jerry on wings , Macintosh im not really sure , cover at the moment i would say but he's got the potential to be good enough.

Just as a matter of interest, Why would Macintosh be so knackered and fatigued.

I've personally seen enough from Macintosh to think he can hold his own in super league. He's not the finished article, but I hope he gets a decent run in the team.

I also want to see simpson keep his place. Very impressed with him vs Leeds.

Catalans was tough, the ref really let them slow it down and they were flying up and basically on the giants players before they had the ball. Always going to be tough for the wingers trying to make yardage.

Was there anything stopping the Giants from flying up and getting on them at the same time as the ball, just asking.

spot on

zero creativity

at least turner can pass out to his centres, thing is we had lawrence at centre after the injury to mellor and he seemed to have forgotten he used to be a centre and how to put a winger in.... oh to have cudjoe back at centre...

maybe poor value but he saved our season last year

poor value is more like smith and symonds