Personally I think Mamo is a better fit for you at FB than Rankin. If Rankin is coming over to play wing then IMO it's just a massive waste

It might be better to wait and see if we really are interested in him before either slagging him off or praising him, depending whether you like him or not.

Myself i thought he was quite decent at Hull, much the same as Turner at Saints, Not a world beater but better than average and in any event it's how players play for you that matters not what they have done before, "I think D Powell would know about that".

We have posters on here wanting Ellis back and others who think the likes of Ferguson and Smith were good buys, so that just shows the difference in peoples opinions, and to be fair we have had players come here with big reputations who have been poor, and we have had players with no particular reputation who have turned out very well.

So much depends on the coach and team spirit, which at the Giants seems to have taken a turn for the better this last few games, so from that point of view now might be a good time for Rankin to come if he is coming, Keep some of the players on their toes so to speak.

For me Rankin is the Australian Lee Gaskell. Similar age and would probably command a similar salary. If he were to sign someone would be making way. If we were signing anyone else I'd want a big prop to keep our momentum when Seb has a rest. Unless Rankin is seen as a partner for Gaskell and long term replacement to Brough I don't really see the point...

getting stronger this rumour now

when he played at hull fc i never really noticed him to be honest, but has nrl pedigree, mixed response from hull fans some love him some dont.

we dont need a full back or winger so must be coming to play in the halves

most clubs have 3 half backs nowadays...

maybe ellis wont return or rankin replacing brough.

also linked with randell from newcastle for 2018 though,. been linked with him ever since stone took over

I think the poster above nailed it, when he likened him to Jordan Turner, he is a decent signing,100% effort and heart on the sleeve, that's why he was well liked by the Hull fans, key is finding his best position, which I think is FB, but he is weak in defensively FB play.

better than connor?

if hes quick then i like that, will add to mamos speed out the back

i like that type of player

wont be full back when we have mamo

i can see it being the halves.. to compliment brough / gaskell... maybe hull didnt find his best position in his time there

He had a number of games at both and never really did it in either for me, certainly better at 1 than 6 though.

Hard to say, been impressed with Connor so far at Hull, played really well at centre and mixed performances at 6, needs a run in one position.

Connor has a lot more potential than Rankin.

Jordan Rankin IS on his way to you lot.

He flies out this week.

Has been playing half back for the Tigers all season.

that will see ridyard go back to leigh id say

Perhaps there was something in the whisper after all, I hope i hear another one about a forward.

yeh looks like a good whisper!

bit like my hunch on us looking at turner

think ridyard will go back to leigh

brough, gaskell, rankin half back options.