Hes still only very young so hopefully they can get this sorted.

James Donaldson(HKR) had the same problem when he was at Bradford when he was 18/19 he was rated extremely highly then had a season ending knee injury. He got back then had the same thing happen again a couple of years later and still managed to come back.

However, 2 days ago he has been ruled out for the season again with a knee ligament issue. Thats 3 serious knee ligament injuries before the age of 25.

I hope Jake doesn't give up but if hes had 2 at the age of 18/19 its doesn't look good.

Conceded 16 points to Swinton in the first 36 mins. No wonder Super League teams are putting loads of points past us, defence is absolutely abysmal. With an Aussie coach I expected the defence, if anything, to be better but it's reversing rapidly in terms of quality.

40 minutes to get out of jail and it's no foregone conclusion !!

How many 1st teamers have you rested today ?

It's certainly not, 22 points conceded now and losing. What a shower of S***

Now 15 minutes to save our season at 18-22 down to the mighty Swinton

24-22 can we hold out for the win?

Didn't think we would be able to hold on!
As a lifelong season ticket holder and sponsor of the club I am now officially finished with my support until they get rid of this clown coach we have in charge. The only money they will see from me now is to purchase a one-way budget next day flight back to Australia for a certain Mr Richard Stone.
I know we have other people connected to the club on here supporting Stone and saying he doesn't drop the ball etc etc but stone picks the team, organises tactics motivates etc and since he came he has made everything 10 times worse than Baloo's reign.
So if anyone at the club reads this get in touch if you are serious and I will buy that ticket.

Spot on. Saying it for weeks. He's a joke, there's no improvement, no structure, no desire, no idea! That is his job!!!

Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear

well done swinton.

giants turned up with the wrong attitude and you get nothing when that happens

total embarrassment and joke today...no defending that.

something needs to be changed and quick

why stop with stone?

the club is rotten from the top

thewlis needs to go too, what about thorman and robbo. what they doing?!

Worst aspect was that some of our 'big' name forwards on long contracts got owned/looked no better than the Swinton championship forwards who have won only two games in that league.

Firstly - very well played Swinton fully deserved so congrats and good luck in the next round.

As for the Giants this result is no great surprise - plenty of fans could see this coming and stayed away. What a waste of £15 to see that. Those of us who went need to shake ourselves cos there must be better more entertaining things to do!

For a professional top league side that performance was shocking - not that we performed at all really. Don't agree with the Stone out comments - too easy to surmise that it is all his fault - regardless of the players selected for this game we did not play as a team - and havn't all season so far. Players have to take some accountability - they are all pro sportsmen.

Personally now fed up of all the dross comments coming from the coach and players about being disappointed, masters of our own downfall, staying positive, looking to put things right next game etc... Time for the talking to stop and be replaced by some collective action on the field where it matters.

Sometimes it is real hard to be a Giants fan - this is not the first time we have been humbled by lower division teams (still getting over the Hunslet game, and Doncaster a few years back) - but biggest issue for me this time is the lack of shock to this result. We are dire this season - even worse than last and destined for the M8's for sure after not learning the lessons - god help us if we end up in the mpg as I honestly could not see us wing that against anyone given our lack of teamwork, and play structure. Getting really worried now.