if we lost 2 of r next 3 games hes gotta go hes taking us no where at all poor in attack n shocking in defence yesterday no effort or motivation at all from the players n surly its andersons job to motivate the players

what if we win 2 out of the next 3, is he good enough then?

no ive never really been a fan of anderson so ill b glad t see him go if he does

Fair enough ,as long as you're not being fickle

so genuine question, who would replace him?

First saying we should sign hock. Now saying brown was good


I call troll

so you're advocating sacking a coach who has improved us from the previous coach, and replace him with a coach like the previous coach
to be fair we did play some good stuff under NB but we also didn't have much in the way of structures etc, despite what people think of our style of "football" etc, we have a very good record under PA.

Because we have been consistent under Anderson, we haven't failed to finish outside the top 4 in his tenure, yes we haven't made a final under him, but we are the best team in the league under Anderson in terms of games played and won, no mean feat.He is also the only coach in 81 years to lead us to a league winners title!

I have nowt against Brown, and rate him highly, he did a fantastic job for us but it just ended badly, but like Anderson, he couldn't get us over the line in terms of trophies, and yes he got us to a cup final, but so did Jon Sharp.

I meant Mr Anderson is the one who will lose his job Meast.

We have been consistent under PA that is true enough, consistent in the brand of football played for the most part, which if you measure the team by where they finish the season you will be happy with. Consistently losing fans as well, which Mr Davy will definitely not be happy with, and to be fair the very fact we are losing fans would seem to suggest the situation will not go on indefinitely.

Anderson actually won something, Brown didn't. Remember 2013? A season and a half after he left Anderson bettered what brown achieved in the league. Yes he got us to a CC final but so did Sharp if we are making comparison's. By your math brown and sharp are as good as each other.

not sure we can blame anderson for how the season has started, we just dont have the players on the field to win the games, when/if we get near out best 17 and back to a settled side and the wins dont come then we can start looking at anderson

Tbf that squad we had out was pretty good- barring huby I'm not convinced any others would have made a difference or is everybody praying for grix to come back now.....

you missed the bit where i said a settled side! including ellis/brough playing together again and having crabtree/rapira/smith/huby (that wont happen this season)

a few other positions too , its like new partnerships every week

widnes are doing well, they have their number one fullback/ half backs / forwards / hookers all fit...but will they cope with injjuries like ours? not many teams would, look at leeds!