I wont mate but imo he should not play in the semi next week .

ahh not just me that has spotted this then!!!

I hear what you are saying although to be fair Eden isn't that bad positionally, the only problem I have with playing Grix at fullback is its another reshuffle we could well do without.

Brown has Grix as a 7, I'm far from convinced but too late to be swapping now, Murphy played fullback at Bradford and had a great game and has done well in all his other outings but we are limited for backs at the moment.

That's why I would go with the team I picked, big mobile nasty pack(if brown allows it) and Broughy pulling the strings.

IMO at the start of this season we should have moved Brown back to centre which IMO is still his best and natural position.

Anyway we can only speculate and just pray for a Giants team who turn up and want to do well. Back to basics and Aggression is the key for me. We beat em at Millenium Magic when they were dropping like flies and didn't want to know, time to muscle up!!

Eden is THAT bad positionally... but guess it will come with more experience. exposed at hull fc and cas most recently

to be fair to eden most of the team were bad positionally at cas and the winning try at hull just about everybody was stood in the middle of the pitch, personally dont think eden is a major concern for me, more like brown,chan, whoever is centre and george on defence, cos can be certain thats were wire will target their attack .

Eden / Grix
Murphy
Gillmore
Cudjoe
George
Brown / Grix
Brough
Eorl
Moore
Mason
Chan
O'Donnel
Faiumu

Interchange:
Larne
Fergie
Fa'alogo
Robbo

This way we have plenty of cover in the forwards which is were this game will be won / lost, we also are able to tighten up our right hand D without losing any go forward

for me team would be
1-eden
2-lawrence
3-cudjoe
4-murphy
5-george
6-brough
7-grix
8-eorl
9 -moore
10- mason
11-chan
12-faalogo
13-fuey
14 -robbo
15-larne
16 -fergie
17 -fairbank/gilmour

drop brown completely think he his awful at the moment

Cant put Lawrence on the wing.


Crackers.

1-Eden
2-Murphy
3-Cudjoe
4-Bruno
5-George
6-Brough
7-Grix
8-Eorl
9 -Moore
10- Mason
11-Chan
12-Faalogo
13-Fuey
14 -Robbo
15-Larne
16 -Fergie
17 -Fairbank

tbc
tbc
tbc
tbc
tbc
tbc
brough
tbc
tbc
tbc
tbc
rbc
brown

subs

tbc
tbc
tbc
tbc

kev brown seems to be getting alot of stick on here, im still a fan of him, top player...

maybe move him back to 7 with brough instead of loose forward and put lee at loose

why cant i put bruno on wing, he was shocking in the centre at cas, plus he would be a good man to stop monaghan

Not sure Bruno should be in the team at the moment. Tackles lots but still doesn't run with any belief, a man that size should be bouncing em off left right and centre.

Brown isn't a 6 and he isn't a 13, not clever enough, coupled with lack of speed off the mark(for a 6) and a poor kicking game, still reckon he would make a decent centre though.

Whatever the team he puts out they are going to have to sharpen up and be prepared to muscle up and get nasty.

Without bruno we'd be conceding a lot more points! He consistently tops the tackle count and few come close! He's just the player we need to cover bridge/Monaghan/Atkins wish we had a couple more of him.

id drop moore and eden

grix,
George,
Lawrence,
Cudjoe,
Murphy,
Brown,
Brough,
Fa'alogo
Robinson,
Mason,
ferguson
gilmour
Fairbank,

Faiumu,
Patrick,
crabtree
Lee,