Sorry, wrong thread.

He was still behind him and dragging though I'll have a second look 2morrow.

Agreed because chase was at the back and he was dragging Grix and how did the ball come out if chase didn't rip it out

anyone who says it was a try then go specsavers. i was at the game and at 1st i thought hes knocked on try but got home watched it and its clear chase has ripped the ball

Just watched it again, I think Kevin Brown gives it away when he tells Ganson he had his ARM pulled, moving the arm is fine because that isn't stripping the ball.

Doesn,t matter what you or anyone else thinks,according to the VR,and the scoreboard it was a try,no amount of watching replays is going to change it,ever.

Watched the decision and thought that Grix was tackled inside the field of play so Pen Hudds. Ganson did not call it ,for whatever reason, so play on. Chase definitely has his hands on the ball then somebody grabs Chase which could have lead to the ball coming loose, so benefit of the doubt.

To be fair 2 on 1 ripping happens in every game. Griffin did it on Holmes in the 2nd half which didn't get seen when we were 10 yard out. So it makes up for that. Eitherway the conversion was missed and we still won by 6 points.


Just so you know. I thought it was ripped but like I said it works both ways when Ganson missed Griffins 2 on 1 rip.

Just about to say that myself CATW, every team does it, i haven't watched it back yet, but at the end of the day the try was given, the game was won, not much you can do now really

we lost, best team won.. lets move on rather than trying to find excuses

Yes, you were better.



[iYou[/i might be able to but the rest of the population couldn't.

I watched the incident and actually thought the guilty look, and arm gesturing from Rangi was to highlight to the ref that he wasn't pulling the player and not what others are saying of him making out he didn't ball steal. That was my immediate thought and watching the replay it made sense to me.

even at the ground we were all convinced he was looking at whether it was a drop out or penalty, not even the cas fans realised he was going for a try! haven't seen the replay but it looked very contentious at the time.

Considering what happened to us last week (ie. taking 3 minutes to disallow the Chev Walker try despite there being obvious doubt as to whether he intentionally knocked on as some camera angles made it look like he didn't even handle it) I was seething with rage at this decision.

Never mind arms here and players gesturing

When Grix took the tackle he clamped the ball to his chest with both arms wrapped around it. There was no way on earth that ball got spilled any other way than by being ripped out.

Clear as day penalty to Hudds.

But then Hudds may have gone on to win and that wouldnt have been fair on a Cas team that played as well as they could.