I'll stand up for Murph.

Together with Michael Lawrence he's been the most consistent player over the last couple of years.

Both underrated by fans but not by their teammates.

Murphy has been very good since he's been at the Giants, however, this year he has been our worst player by far.... Hopefully he can pick his form back up..

In my opinion Bruno has been our best player this year.

Would agree with this

oli roberts has been great and can see him been our no1 2nd rower in a couple of years

agreed Murphy has been our worst player this year, looks to have lost speed, strength, everything.

Murphy was my favourite player last year by a mile, but I'm concerned or him this year - he looks a shadow of the player he was last season.

I think he is carrying a significant injury. Anybody else noticed that he leaves the warm-up about 10 minutes before everyone else? Why would this be - injections?

All that can affect confidence which we know in turn can affect form.

BTW, I think Taai is our most consistent performer this year

yes loose forward could be an option for connor but i fear he is just turning into a utility player that can fill in a few positions, master of none.

murphy not super league quality? stopped reading after that comment.

oh and bailey could have been great at loose forward for us but he was injured most of the time , torn bicep. he got a few games back end of season when fit but was poor.

broughton was ousted by murphy and rightly so on the form he was in last season.

cudjoe

rapira

taai


our best performers so far this season.

tony smith available at the end of season?? still lives in west yorkshire.. is it hudds?

sorry just putting it out there

Murphy my favourite player last year. If he's not giving 110% then I would say he's injured in some way.

Murphy is 100% super league quality. There is absolutely no doubt about it... He's struggling for form at the minute and is definitely standing out as an under performer. But this happens to all players at some point in there careers. I'm sure he is disappointed with himself and is working extra hard to put things right. I doubt his poor form will last much longer.

And I will agree with Brearley regarding Taai, rapira and Leroy... Have to throw Jerry in there too and Bruno.

It's playing as a team that is our main problem, individually we're not too bad..

personally I have my doubts about trying to convert a halfback with pace into a full back. Someone had that great idea with a halfback on the verge of playing at international level and it was just about curtain down for the lad He too had pace--and of similar build and whilst there wasnt a lot wrong with his tackling technique with the big fellas at pace it was all too often try time!

As Isaid in another post Hodson was a "special" at full back and although fairly slight framed his tackling technique for his size was flawless
i get fed up of trying to convert players signed whilst playing in a position theyve learned their trade to different roles Just my opinion

So i hope the recent signing of this lad with potential isnt wasted by experimentation
Let him settle in with us where he got noticed and then see how he goes
Saw bruno in a cup semi at Salford afterhe`d been tried at centre and wingman playing as he does now in the 2nd row Quite honestly the poor fella didnt seem to know where he should postion himself. Good as he is now in that role I would have preferred to keep his pace (with his then size) and tackled as he does to close that space down --much as we`d like Connor to do now iot apperas on here
think some times when ive seen the team sheet they put the positions in a hat! - and its spot the permutation!

bulletproof vest at the ready!!