thought shudds did really well tonight. just could not quite find the killer play when they needed it.

great season for them tho, still thought they could have nicked it!

played really well untill the 61st minute then we gave away some bad penalties off the back of good deep kicks steve wild with some poor high tackles which is unlike him but all in all i think the lads did well and made a game of it i hope saints go on to win it this year please save us from having to listen to wigan go on and on about being back at the top

I am not heartbroken. They players gave 110% but silly penalties gave them field position and we could not stop the juggernauts in the last third of the field.

we were beat by the better team. I feel a lot better after tonight than i did at Wembley 2009.

Proud of all the Giants players and fans tonight.

Well played Huddersfield you played some decent rugby tonight but we went up a gear when Keiron came back on, God we are going to miss him.

agree with everything on here, disappointed yes,but not heartbroken,we will be back to win the thing in the next 5 years!!
was a pleasure to be a part of the occasion of the last game at knowsley road,a great game which for most parts i thought we were the better team,but ultimately saints had the edge in the last 10-15 minutes,helped by giving away 5 penalties on the go, 4 of which led to tries, if we hadn't given those away, who knows? but i am still mighty proud of the boys in claret and gold after this season

If im being honest i think you lot have the makings of a very good team. Maybe 3 players short of a real threat to saints, leeds and wigan.

I think you play some good rugby and have big tough pack and a great young coach.


Not sure if you've signed anyone for next year but a few new faces and i think you'll go a step closer maybe next year.

Just state of origin player Luke O'Donnell so far from the Cowboys but there's some quality players in talks at the moment who improve on our starting 13.

my view was we lost our discipline when saints started getting on a roll and tried stopping them but gave away silly penalties which they capitalised on .
We weren't disgraced by any means as maybe the scoreline suggests and with a bit more composure and discipline we could be queueing for tickets this morning

funny how when giants took the lead the referee was suddenly a w**ker. Now thats what i call supporters!!! typical saints, salt of the earth.

There needs to be because Wild will be a bigger loss than many think and Bodgy is not only a leader of men but as safe under the high ball as any full back in the league. Two big, big losses.

Very good signing Luke O'Donnell will be if he ain't banned every week.

He will fit into your pack and improve you a hell of alot, imo your short of a top class centre.

Who will be your fullback next year?

Rumours are Grix will fill the position

Disappointed - but not heartbroken. Saints are a top side and have been for ages - our time will and is coming. Not so long ago we would never dream of being 80 mins from the GF. Thought we tried really hard and showed some class to get back on level terms after a slow start. Saints took full advantage of some silly penalties in second half - and they are too good when invited in to our 20 metres.

KC and Wellens were excellent and what a kicker that Foster is.

Good luck to Saints in the final - maybe next time for us!

got to echo the comments on here not heartbroken, just very proud of our team,support and club. probably one of the best games i have attended in 40 years of watching the club for the sense of the occasion at saints last home game at kr, the way our team stood toe to toe with saints and the best support i can ever remember behind the giants, never heard us so loud before long may it continue, i think our time is coming soon.