He does lose the ball in the tackle sometimes, Not as often as Tai but they both put some effort into it. Grix has his good sides to his game, Taking the ball up and tackling are not amongst them, It's a matter of If the advantages outweigh the disadvantages with most fullbacks, They cant all be Steve Prescott's or Gary Connolly's.

Totally agree, We might see some class players " which I welcome" we might not, but they will be at the clubs who already win everything, so I don't see much changing.

You have presented a point which I cannot argue against, so I accept I was wrong. I rescind my previous comment on Grix.

You have presented a point which I cannot argue against, so I accept I was wrong. I rescind my previous comment on Grix.

It's one of the reasons I think this forum for Giants fans is great. A chance to put your view forward and at the same time give others a chance to change your mind - I know the forum has challenged and changed my point of view at times! I had to laugh last night when we agreed 100% on another thread but completely disagreed on this one (thankfully others were more eloquent than me on this one!).

That's very magnanimous of you. I second the

.

As long as Scott Grix is contracted to - and long after he has left - Huddersfield Giants RLFC there will be mixed opinions on him...we know that throughout his career with us.
Same to a point with Paul Anderson now, some think he's taken us as far as he can while others think we haven't had the best yet and are happy with what is happening at the club ie Full time Academy = more homegrown talent etc.

Either way as fans of the club all we can do is support both blokes while they wear those famous colours of ours !!

sure everyone wants the answer to that one! we can only keep trying ...will see when the next big game comes around as to whether we have got the answer

Tomorrow is the next big game and Wigan are a side we often do well against, If we front up like we did first half last week I'm optimistic. Can't be there unfortunately but might get a bit of radio if I'm lucky, Can you pick up Radio Leeds on West coast ?.

No- but you can listen to radio Leeds online. If you don't have that option Might be better trying to pick up a local Wigan station. - diesnt look like BBC Lancashire is doing it.

By big game game i mean in a play off game or cup game.

yes the league games are very important to get us too them and the next 3 games are going to go along way to whether we finish in the top 4, unfortunately our injuries have come at just the wrong time

up against it tomorrow cant see us winning but hope we do. warrington next too!

The whole match is being covered on BBC Radio Five Live Extra. If you can't get a digital radio try BBC Mancester or Wish FM.

Thanks for that but didn't get to hear any of it in the end, Sounds to have been a game of two halves again though reading the thread.