That's a great post !!

when at the games and people are screaming at Grix to 'run hard, run straight ' etc and then they moan when he passes it ! i've said to many people have you ever thought it's a tactic, a coach's order to do it rather than Grix actually choosing not to himself ??.

Or maybe they want him to run in hard, get smashed, drop the ball etc so they can then have a go at him for that !
Like i've always said 1st carry is all about safety and if the safest way is to pass to a winger to run it in hard for 1st collision then that's fine with me. If it is a weakness of Grixy then surely that is good coaching to not have him doing it in the 1st place ?

l have long been a fan of Grix, in the first years he had to change position a lot, but in my humble opinion he is the best FB we have at this time.
Further comments l will keep till seasons end, and the 5 to stay, and 5 to go post.

Oh dear, the only joke on here is your crap opinion

Spot on, some folk just haven't got a clue

Good to see some people with a bit of sense on here

Anderson gets a new 2 year deal so that will upset the creater of this thread!

arguments for and against really but right now its the right choice, won the LLS , backed it up with a 3rd place finish and currently 4th in the table...the majority of clubs would love to swap places with us!

Well I'm no big fan of PA, but it certainly won't upset me. I can choose to go and support or not, It's more about style of play and entertainment for me, That's just me , some will be far more bothered about finishing high up the league, Points are everything sort of, That's fine as well cause they can choose whether to go or not as well.

I am not particularly impressed with finishing 4th, 3rd or whatever if we just keep getting wiped out in the playoff's. We did extremely well to win the LLS, and though I think it's wrong, it's viewed as a runners up trophy by most RL fans. I don't recall any increase in attendances of any note either, so if that's the case maybe it's true.

In my opinion our style of play has gone backwards in the last season and half, there will be many reasons for that I suppose but again in my opinion PA is one of them, We have some players who have gone backwards, some who haven't.

The biggest case to be made for PA is probably that we don't have the quality of players (generally ) that the so called big clubs do, Probably true enough, My main problem is if we can still be 3
-4 th in the league after playing like we have for the last season and half a lot of the time, What could we do if we played like we are capable of, and show we are capable of in odd matches,( sometimes Half matches ).

That for me is where the top coaches can, by various different styles get the very best out of the players, This is where I think PA is lacking. I may be quite wrong , but it is my opinion only.

I'm very interested to hear other peoples reasons why he should have gone or stayed, All hypothetical now but still worth hearing.

The fact he actually catches it is a massive benefit compared to what we've had before ......

It's great finishing 3rd or 4th. But what's the point when we bottle it once we are there.

Daz mentioned Grix giving possession away by losing the ball in collision hence why he passes it.

Here's a thought. How about a FB that can take a tackle without losing the ball!!!

Just a thought.

Be nice if some of our bigger guys could manage that too....

Jerry drops the ball in the collision every other hit up it seems

think he loses it trying to get us a quick play of the ball, which sometimes inturn also wins us a penalty for the opposition messing about in the ruck

as a team we need to be able to raise our game and intensity when the big games come, the teams that win the trophies are the ones that can do that, they can turn it on and off

we cant at the moment, look at the leeds game they went up a few gears and we failed to match them despite being able to win league games with ease at times

And what do you see as a solution.

One thing's for sure- it's not the bloomin marquee ruling!