should Nathan go now

I think he should go now.

Players are not playing for a coach who is going elsewhere.

WE had this last season and he could not lift them and we limped to the end of the season.
Look at Robinsons comments after losing to Salford today. All NB can say is players confidence is down. WHY?.

constantly changing things does not breed confidence and playing players out of position causes uncertainty.

I might change my avatar to Huddersfield Giants where no player is specialised enough to play in their position.
Let Anderson take over now with a clean slate and let players know they are playing for their jobs next year.

When Boyd2 says NB is losing the dressing room i have to accept that. If it is the scase do not let the cancer spread

I think the opinion of a lot is that Nathan should take 'Leave' and let Baloo take over , Nothing against NB but we dont know how committed he still is to our cause when he is trying to build a squad at Saints for next year.

not only that i would hate for him to be the target of a hate campaign or to a point where he leaves us with hostilities, he has done a great job in his time here and should always be remembered by us for that .........i do think if this form and insistence on weird team selections continue then people will become hostile towards him and for this reason and the fact that i also think he has half an eye on whats happening at Saints too then maybe it is time for him to call time on his career here and leave with our best wishes.

Nb has been great - and brought us a long way, and as daz days should leave positively.
Last season I kept the faith , but this is so déjà vu , and we want a better end third of season this year.
Best outcome for all if he resigns.
Tomorrow.

Mate heard from squad player that players very confused and frustrated with the rotation policy.

NB has been great for us but this mid term season slump trend is becoming really tedious. Past two seasons it has been worrying to think he may go and what we would do without him. This year is worse cos we know exactly that he is going, where, and when, and who will replace him.

Don't expect he will go but worried what effect all this is having on the cohesion of the team.

So frustrating to see us make a far better start than expected (due to injuries early on), do well to maintain it, then 4 defeats in a row!!!

HKR on Monday will make this 5 unless something pretty fundamental changes

do all those voting want to leave a post so we know others are not interfering in the vote.

Fair enough Durham Giant , i voted for N.B to go now as he has to take the blame for that `train crash waiting to happen` of a team selection at widnes, i thought i was hearing things when they announced our team , then when we went behind we just fell to pieces abd NO ONE was directing the team on the pitch as we had NO CAPTAIN worth his salt , thanks for the memories N.B ., get your coat on theres the door , hand over to Balloo.

After my post yesterday when I said maybe its time for Nathan to go now in hindsight I think he should stay and turn things around. It would be a very sad end to his time here but clearly things need addressing. This is the best chance we have to win something for many a year and I would hate for some mid season mini crisis to de-rail that. We always hear the players are a tight knit group well let them prove it. Its been a nightmare 4 weeks but as they say 'nowts won in May' - look at Leeds last year.

C'MON YOU GIANTS.

We listened to Radio Leeds on way back home and Jamie Bloem said `they don`t turn into a bad team overnight `, well NO its taken us 4 weeks to do that , we are in freefall at the moment and will N.B be able to stop the rot?. He picked that team at widnes and cobbled together his gameplan only for it to be torn up after about 15 mins , WHY so many positional changes ? , over to you N.B. ,no doubt the examiner will be the same old drivel this week on how they will `train hard all week BLAH BLAH BLAH.

I think his new pay packet at St Helens has gone to his head. His current salary at Huddersfield isn't worth getting out of bed for in comparison.

yes think he should go, said as soon as it was annonced hes off to saints that if we had a bad run he could be off...bad run is here ... maybe it will take 6/7 defeats in the trot though for him to go.

The worry is if he does go and things don't improve Baloo starts his coaching career on a downer and is under pressure from the start next year when it is all his decisions as for the rest of this season he would only be able to modify things not stamp his own style and beliefs on the club.

Hopefully NB's sense of pride is hurt and he will turn it round before the Semi Final but the jury has to be out either way.

maybe a poisoned chalice for anderson anyhow this job

Could well be but sometimes it works sometimes it does not and think he needs a pre-season to give it his best shot but he will not have a say in how things pan out on when he takes charge and if it gets dumped in his lap now he will just have to get on with it, then again take us to Wembley and Old Trafford from here and it will not have turned out so bad.

No.

no i dont think he should go now at all, cant see the point in that, think last 2 results poor but to put that down to bad coaching or him taking his eye of the giants is insulting to nb to me.