Good job Thaler was on the ball today, not only with reversing the refs bad calls on the two no tries, but also with the call for a Catalan goal line drop out, and then over ruling a head and feed scrum when the ball clearly came off a Cats player and hit Sam Rapira

Then keep Gaskell at 6 and Sam Wood at centre

Playing someone because they are solid and dependable won't win us points

Murphy is a centre always was utterly wasted on the wing - anybody who knows RL can see that surely.

I've always been a big fan of smurf ... always gives 100% ... rarely misses tackles or makes errors. Carries the ball well and can play anywhere in the outside backs. So to say he is 'utterly wasted' is a bit harsh.

scores a fair few tries as a winger too does murphy!

You may have thought that but we have tacticians who know better. He plays a good game get's MOM and it's only because he was playing against a poor side. We also have a International who missed a tackle my Grandaughter could have made, that resulted in a try,Playing against the same poor side , but there will be a myriad of reasons for that.

The argument is that he is OK but will not win us games, that makes him in good company then, Apart from a couple on their day, we have a team full like him.