What is a little odd is that when Lunt went. Thewlis said announcements on other players futures would be made over the following week or so. I assumed Fairbank (announced a couple of days later) and Eden. Makes me wonder if things have gone as smoothly as we hope.

What's the big deal here? Both sides of the perceived "argument" are correct. Eden is clearly a talented and exciting player. Also, he clearly makes too many errors. There's nothing wrong with stating either of those points.

Where have I said all I want is titles? Show me. Or are you resorting to making up my posts? oh dear. Tilting at windmills

I don't think supporting the Giants and wanting titles should be mutually exclusive. maybe you do. I do think winning titles and making lots of errors in your 20/30M (especially when the opposition dont even have possession) are probably mutually exclusive.

All the posts I have seen suggestiing that Eden needs to make significant cuts in his errors have not questioned GEs ability. Quite the contrary. I was sooo critical that I suggested that if GE cuts his errors he will soon be an England player (harsh I know )

There are some posters who are not only happy to plod along with all these 'learning' errors. they resort to saying posters like me want GE dropped, that we know nothing about the game and even question whether we are genuine supporters (pathetic i know). All because as Giants supporters some posters think that around 3 errors a game, mainly in our 20/30M and mainly when the opposition do not have possession is not consistent with winning titles.

i see what you're getting at If we sign the entire Queensland squad and GE becomes the best full back in the world then we could win something...agreed.