Maybe once this is all over and assuming off course no action is taken, we will all be able to see the footage for ourselves.

anyone can Derek only cost £5

we should all boycott the game if thats the case

Sorry Fred I missed that info off the end of my post

I understand you Rob. Thanks for the information. I think the 4th official had an unenviable task on Sunday. He must have had at least 20 bodies surrounding him, (sounds incredible, but work it out, with subs, trainers, water carriers, physios, doctors, kitmen etc.) in cramped conditions. Maybe the RFL should be able to enlist/fund the interchange officials for both teams - and give the 4th official a chance. It would also help him if he didn't have the MC stood beside him, giving him constant earache - when Ged Stokes allowed him to get a word in!

Oddly enough, something similar happened in our previous game against Featherstone. Andy Kain was waiting to come on, while Nanyn was kicking at goal. I guess Kain was standing about a foot inside the touchline. Suddenly Robert Hicks yellow carded him and allowed Fev to retain 13 men. It wasn't clear why Hicks crded him, but if itwas for encroaching, it was petty. However, Fev had a sub yellow carded, but were allowed to retain a full team. Granted the sub hadn't actually created a try, but still similar circumstances.

If he was on the field then they had 14 men on, perhaps we should appeal and ask for a re-match?

Look up the word ALLEGATIONS it actually has nothing to do with the law, which part of geds rant do you want me to refute? I will answer to the RFL thank you very much not to you, I am not wearing red and white specs at all and can only see what my camera recorded which is in the hands (well will be in the morning) of the RFL, straw clutching by haven at least mischief at worst, a petty incident blown up out of all proportion by a man clinging onto a job, absolutely pathetic, and you lot have swallowed it hook line and sinker.

Fred, have you looked at the incident where the Leigh water carrier got sent off? Was it a stoppage or not? We could be looking at getting into trouble for that also...

Best thing is; Replay the game with our strongest team out, have the RFL in attendence and, take the bl@@dy Bonus point off them good style!

Outcome will be [hopefully] the officials will have to be retrained as it seems they did not do there job,can't see any other outcome or teams will be wanting replays for forward passes next

No, I wouldn't expect my team to ask for a replay because a sub dropped his card on the floor as he replaced a player. In fact I would be embarrassed if they did.

But who says he dropped it, maybe the 4th official dropped it. Have you seen the video of the incident yet?

fred you need to read my post again .When i said i didnt know the law ,i meant the rfl rules on these type of incidents not the law about allegations
i made no allegations simply said that 13 or 14 men was not the issue
the facts are duffy was sent off for illegally entering the field of play and that was in the MC report
As you even say in your own report duffy was involved in robbies try so he influnced how the game went while on the field illegally they are facts
We are simply using our right of appeal not clutching at straws.If your honest if the circumstances were reversed leigh would do exactley the same.
For what its worth i dont think anything other than a fine for the player will come of this.Seen as all the other subs for haven and leigh went without a hitch then this one is either duffys fault or the 4th officals and i can't see the rfl blaming themselves.
i for one dont want a replay,if some one had offered me a BP AT 2.55Pm on sunday i would have grab their had off