I'm not sure I watched the same game as the rest of you.... how many times did we hold them for a set of six in their own half? Behind their own 30 sometimes too.... not the sign of a bad defensive team? OK, we still need some go forward, but even there we had our moments. We could have scored another 20 if we'd not made stupid errors - Stanton was screaming for the ball at one point in the second half and would have been away with it, Nanyn got selfish, we got taken into touch how many times?
Lots of positives, but we really do need more power up front, until we get that we're going to struggle in the middle of the table.
Stanton should have got MOM for me, always looking, always active, and he looks a right bugger to tackle!

Having said all that, I feel sorry for Oldham next week, I suspect we'll tear them to bits.

And a win over Wigan is a win over Wigan, no matter how you look at it!

10-0 and we went to sleep, never seen the marker take the ball from the acting half before he passed it before Bombed a couple of walk ins second half and scored when we needed to.
Saw enough in the first 20 to be confident, although Higson must start in the centre and Armistead dropped.

Yeah I don't really 'get' Armitstead as a player. Don't see him as a 13 but more as a prop. But he wouldn't be in our 1st 4/5 props if they were all fit. He takes a lot of drives in and tackles well but he tends to do 1 or 2 stupid offloads in the tackle EVERY week which is pretty frustrating

Army actually played a good deal of that game as a prop, he had to as we didn't have enough of them wearing shirts today.

Fantastic till we went 10-0 up. Next hour was spent trying to warm my hands back up. then the last 5 mins were thrilling. W*gan played well IMO, and tested our defence well. As for the flute song - WHY do the 'fans' insist on singing it?????

My big bugbear is as to why the turnstiles were so bl**dy slow ....

we must use our wings more instead of one man rugby could have scored 3 or 4 more with open play

That was in February 2007. Only two of yesterday's Wigan team played in that game.

Really??

He does try but got a LOT to learn, he always seems to be heading for a gap but then steps in towards the tackler?!?!

I thought we did pretty well on Sunday.

LAst year we were dreadful....
haemoraging penalties, trying to score off evey play, daft off loads, clueless in fromnt of the try line.

Yesterday, i thought we had more structure, varied play and playing in a fashion our players could deal with. When we got near the try line, we looked liked we knew what to do, which is a first in 3 years i think.

Not even IM can turn the players from last year into the Harlem Globetrotters in less than 3 months and two games.

I was encouraged by the game yesterday and felt we have improved in important areas.

The flute song is just unedifying for all concerned.

Well it certainly stimulates my anger that the club don't come out and publiclly distance themselves from it.

The game as a whole Paul I have to agree with you. There are some good signs coming from what I have seen. I love the way we seem to have improved the quick passing. We were stiffled by the young Wigan lads moving up quick and thats a lesson that we should learn as we seem to have times when we just hold back instead of meeting them at the line of srummage. That was a massive part of our game when IM was here last. Not too depressed about yesterday as has been said these Wigan players are future SL players and maybe internationals. I know it's only two friendlies but I really don't know about Hartley. I personally think Ridy is the better option and am relieved that he has re-signed. On the Wigan team I like the look of their 1, 4 and 8. Congratulations should go out to the Wigan fans also for turning out in such numbers. Well done Pies.

He was finding gaps and no one passed it to him.

Well said that man.

penalty count was 7 - 3, so thats 13 penalties conceded so far in two games, which taken in context over last year is a remarkable improvement.

Couldn't agree more Mr C, especially the last bit.