That is what ive been saying for a while now , personally i would have offloaded Ostick and Jimmy T , and gone for a Big Robust Prop , problem is where from ?That is the Question .

I reckon it's:

McNally; Maden; Littler; Gardner; Pownall; Ridyard; Brierley; Ostick; Parker; Beswick; Penkywicz; Nicholson; Duffy; Briscoe; Hopkins; Goulden; Fiinigan; Aspinwall; Thornley.

I now await correction!

I think you have called it about right , i still think we need a Big experienced Prop , and a good winger.

Is Duffy doing another season Alan?

charlie, We have one of the most exciting players in the league on one wing and one of the most reliable hardworking players on the other wing. What would you class as a good winger?

Think he's a prop from Wire leyther geezer, don't know if he is related to John.

I recall him now I thought the owd boy might of had a change of heart

Someone asked John if he was related. He guiltily enquired how old he was

love child

Totally agree about Jonny P , and i like Maden , but he isnt getting any younger , we need speed on the flanks to support our pack for next season , and may need a little strength in depth , thats what has let us down in the play-offs .

As for my idea of a GOOD WINGER , one who is Big , Fast , Fearless , and knows his way to the try line , i dont know if we will get one though .

And a BIG ROBUST PROP .

Seems Charlie doesn't know after all

Re big robust props' what is wrong with Spencer (if we can get him ) we then have Parker Duffy Ostick (who improved as the season went on) then Sam Hopkins.

Think Ballard would improve our backline quite honestly. Hope we can land him.

Good goal kicker as well.

I take it Ballard hasn't put pen to paper with swinton I hope not I'd be chuffed if we signed him