So where was he when the referee noticed he was offside and blew his whistle or do you not know when he was offside?

If he was behind the back row of his forwards when the ball was put in the scrum then he is onside. It doesn't say what happens next or where he has to be when the ball comes out. It only talks about the other players not connected with the scrum being 5 yards back when the ball comes out!!!!

Starbug here

As he should have done later in the game when Miller stood exactly where Ryan stood and then moved horizontally across the pitch and tackled our 1 st receiver

This happens in every match , so why is a penalty never given ?

Perhaps he didn't spot it, I didn't until I watched the recording.

Because the ball isn't in play until the ball leaves the scrum. Thank god it is the last one.

So why did he wave play on for Riley then. Cos it was obvious that the ball was kicked out of Kays hands. Penalty Leigh not knock on

How was it obvious? The hands on the ball happened in the same frame as reilly getting a boot on it. As for the offside, pretty certain it said that in the following weeks rugby press so yes it was offside.

Oooh, I've got a question!

The RFL introduced a new interpretation of obstruction, the one that allows you to throw yourself on the floor to avoid conceding a penalty. Is there are random element to the decision on the new interpretation - "throw a dice, roll a 6 - it's a penalty!" - or are referees simply proving incapable of understanding what is supposed to be happening?

It's giving me an internal struggle as I decide if I should be incandescent with rage when a penalty is given for obstruction or when it's not because the player lied down to have his belly tickled.

P.S. I do understand that if you try to take advantage of the obstruction then it is a penalty.

That is when it started to go wrong, there has been too many interpretations that cloud the issue. Attacking player prevents defender tackling ball carrier then a penalty is awarded for obstruction. That will do.

Should have been obvious for the TJ,he was a matter of feet away.And after viewing the video, Brierley wasn't actually offside,the ref missed the pace..

Pics available if required.

Send them to the RFL - I'm sure they'll overturn the result and give you the points retrospectively.

ha ha...nice one !

Think some people need to move on and get over it.

Only 3 posts in 2 days and none of them really on topic so I think most people probably have. But thanks for pointing that out.